arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2304.06401cs.CV

为什么现有多模态人群计数数据集可能导致现实应用中的期望落空

Why Existing Multimodal Crowd Counting Datasets Can Lead to Unfulfilled Expectations in Real-World Applications

Hochschule Darmstadt(达姆施塔特应用技术大学)

Martin Thißen, Elke Hergenröther

AI总结:

本文利用现有多模态人群计数数据集系统比较单模态与多模态模型,发现现有数据集偏向热图像,无法普遍回答多模态是否更优,并提出未来数据集构建标准。

摘要:

更多信息会带来更好的决策和预测,对吗?多项研究证实了这一假设,认为同时使用光学图像和热图像可以在人群计数中获得更好的预测。然而,多模态模型从两种模态中提取丰富特征的方式尚未被完全理解。由于使用多模态数据通常会增加模型的复杂度、推理时间和内存需求,因此有必要研究多模态模型相比单模态模型的差异和优势。本文使用所有可用的多模态人群计数数据集来研究单模态模型与多模态模型之间的差异。为此,我们设计了一种单模态架构,该架构考虑了当前单模态人群计数的研究现状。此外,我们还使用不同的多模态学习策略开发了多种多模态架构。单模态架构的关键组件同样被用于多模态架构中,以便回答多模态模型在人群计数中是否总体上表现更好。令人惊讶的是,从现有数据集中无法得出这一问题的普遍答案。我们发现现有数据集对热图像存在偏差。这一发现是通过分析光学图像亮度与人群数量之间的关系,以及检查每个数据集所做的标注得出的。由于回答这一问题对于未来人群计数的现实应用非常重要,本文建立了一套适用于潜在数据集的标准,以判断多模态模型在人群计数中是否总体上表现更好。

英文摘要:

More information leads to better decisions and predictions, right? Confirming this hypothesis, several studies concluded that the simultaneous use of optical and thermal images leads to better predictions in crowd counting. However, the way multimodal models extract enriched features from both modalities is not yet fully understood. Since the use of multimodal data usually increases the complexity, inference time, and memory requirements of the models, it is relevant to examine the differences and advantages of multimodal compared to monomodal models. In this work, all available multimodal datasets for crowd counting are used to investigate the differences between monomodal and multimodal models. To do so, we designed a monomodal architecture that considers the current state of research on monomodal crowd counting. In addition, several multimodal architectures have been developed using different multimodal learning strategies. The key components of the monomodal architecture are also used in the multimodal architectures to be able to answer whether multimodal models perform better in crowd counting in general. Surprisingly, no general answer to this question can be derived from the existing datasets. We found that the existing datasets hold a bias toward thermal images. This was determined by analyzing the relationship between the brightness of optical images and crowd count as well as examining the annotations made for each dataset. Since answering this question is important for future real-world applications of crowd counting, this paper establishes criteria for a potential dataset suitable for answering whether multimodal models perform better in crowd counting in general.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑