因果确认测量:从Simpson's Paradise到COVID-19
Causal Confirmation Measures: From Simpson's Paradox to COVID-19
摘要:
当我们比较两种原因对结果的影响时,如果每一组的结论都与合并的结论相反,我们认为存在辛普森悖论。现有因果推理理论通过排除混杂因素的影响,消除悖论,使总体结论与分组结论一致。ECIT使用相对风险差Pd = max(0,(R - 1)/R)(R表示风险比)作为因果关系的概率。与此相反,哲学家菲特森使用确认测度D(后验概率减去先验概率)来衡量因果关系的强度。Fitelson总结说,从贝叶斯证实的角度来看,我们应该直接接受总体结论,而不考虑悖论。作者提出了一个类似于Pd的贝叶斯确认测度b*。为了克服ECIT与贝叶斯证实之间的矛盾,作者利用语义信息方法,在最小交叉熵准则下推导出因果证实测度Cc =(R-1)/max(R,1)。Cc类似于Pd,但具有归一化性质(在-1和1之间)并导致对称性。它特别适合原因限制结果的情况,例如控制感染的COVID-19疫苗。一些例子(关于肾结石治疗和COVID-19)表明Pd和Cc比D更合理; Cc比Pd更有用。
英文摘要:
When we compare the influences of two causes on an outcome, if the conclusion from every group is against that from the conflation, we think there is Simpson's Paradox. The Existing Causal Inference Theory (ECIT) can make the overall conclusion consistent with the grouping conclusion by removing the confounder's influence to eliminate the paradox. The ECIT uses relative risk difference Pd = max(0, (R - 1)/R) (R denotes the risk ratio) as the probability of causation. In contrast, Philosopher Fitelson uses confirmation measure D (posterior probability minus prior probability) to measure the strength of causation. Fitelson concludes that from the perspective of Bayesian confirmation, we should directly accept the overall conclusion without considering the paradox. The author proposed a Bayesian confirmation measure b* similar to Pd before. To overcome the contradiction between the ECIT and Bayesian confirmation, the author uses the semantic information method with the minimum cross-entropy criterion to deduce causal confirmation measure Cc = (R -1)/max(R, 1). Cc is like Pd but has normalizing property (between -1 and 1) and cause symmetry. It especially fits cases where a cause restrains an outcome, such as the COVID-19 vaccine controlling the infection. Some examples (about kidney stone treatments and COVID-19) reveal that Pd and Cc are more reasonable than D; Cc is more useful than Pd.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。