arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2403.00957stat.MEcs.AImath.PRphysics.data-anstat.AP
收藏

辛普森悖论通过共同原因原理的解决

Resolution of Simpson's paradox via the common cause principle

Alikhanyan National Laboratory(阿里哈尼扬国家实验室);Institute of Applied Problems of Physics(应用物理问题研究所);Yerevan State University(埃里温国立大学)

A. Hovhannisyan, A. E. Allahverdyan

AI总结:

本文通过共同原因原理解决辛普森悖论,证明在最小设定下应选择对 $B$ 条件化的选项,而非边缘化。

摘要:

辛普森悖论是在给定第三个(潜在)随机变量 $B$ 的情况下,建立两个事件 $a_1$ 和 $a_2$ 之间概率关联的一个障碍。我们关注随机变量 $A$(包含 $a_1$、$a_2$ 及其补集)和 $B$ 具有一个共同原因 $C$ 的场景,该原因 $C$ 无需被观测到。或者,我们可以假设 $C$ 将 $A$ 从 $B$ 中分离出来。对于这种情况,$a_1$ 和 $a_2$ 之间的正确关联应通过对 $C$ 的条件化来定义。这一设定推广了原始的辛普森悖论:现在它的两个矛盾选项对应于两个特定且不同的原因 $C$。我们证明,如果 $B$ 和 $C$ 是二元的,而 $A$ 是四元的(辛普森悖论的最小且最普遍的情况),则对任何二元共同原因 $C$ 的条件化所建立的 $a_1$ 和 $a_2$ 之间的关联方向,与原始悖论表述中对 $B$ 的条件化所建立的关联方向相同。因此,对于最小共同原因,应选择辛普森悖论中假设对 $B$ 条件化而非边缘化的选项。当辛普森悖论通过 3 个连续高斯变量来表述时,也得出同样的结论:在悖论的最小表述(3 个标量连续变量 $A_1$、$A_2$ 和 $B$)中,应选择对 $B$ 条件化的选项。

英文摘要:

Simpson's paradox is an obstacle to establishing a probabilistic association between two events $a_1$ and $a_2$, given the third (lurking) random variable $B$. We focus on scenarios when the random variables $A$ (which combines $a_1$, $a_2$, and their complements) and $B$ have a common cause $C$ that need not be observed. Alternatively, we can assume that $C$ screens out $A$ from $B$. For such cases, the correct association between $a_1$ and $a_2$ is to be defined via conditioning over $C$. This setup generalizes the original Simpson's paradox: now its two contradicting options refer to two particular and different causes $C$. We show that if $B$ and $C$ are binary and $A$ is quaternary (the minimal and the most widespread situation for the Simpson's paradox), the conditioning over any binary common cause $C$ establishes the same direction of association between $a_1$ and $a_2$ as the conditioning over $B$ in the original formulation of the paradox. Thus, for the minimal common cause, one should choose the option of Simpson's paradox that assumes conditioning over $B$ and not its marginalization. The same conclusion is reached when Simpson's paradox is formulated via 3 continuous Gaussian variables: within the minimal formulation of the paradox (3 scalar continuous variables $A_1$, $A_2$, and $B$), one should choose the option with the conditioning over $B$.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑