辛普森悖论的再认识:一个统计错误描述的视角
Revisiting Simpson's Paradox: a statistical misspecification perspective
摘要:
本文的主要目的是重新辛普森悖论使用统计错误的角度来看。有人认为,统计关联的逆转有时是虚假的,源于对数据的无效概率假设。统计错误的概念是用来正式模糊的术语“虚假的结果”作为“统计上不可信的”推理结果。这种观点通过区分统计上可信与不可信的关联反转,为悖论提供了新的视角。事实证明,在这两种情况下,都没有什么违反直觉的东西需要解释或说明。这种观点也被用来重新审视因果的悖论的“决议”,试图描绘的建模和推理问题所提出的统计错误的观点。使用文献中的实际和假设数据来说明主要论点,包括尤尔的“无意义相关性”和伯克利招生研究。
英文摘要:
The primary objective of this paper is to revisit Simpson's paradox using a statistical misspecification perspective. It is argued that the reversal of statistical associations is sometimes spurious, stemming from invalid probabilistic assumptions imposed on the data. The concept of statistical misspecification is used to formalize the vague term `spurious results' as `statistically untrustworthy' inference results. This perspective sheds new light on the paradox by distingusing between statistically trustworthy vs. untrustworthy association reversals. It turns out that in both cases there is nothing counterintuitive to explain or account for. This perspective is also used to revisit the causal `resolution' of the paradox in an attempt to delineate the modeling and inference issues raised by the statistical misspecification perspective. The main arguments are illustrated using both actual and hypothetical data from the literature, including Yule's "nonsense-correlations" and the Berkeley admissions study.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。