arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2001.07566cs.AIcs.ITmath.ITmath.LO
收藏

经络的证实与预言的证实:从医学检验到乌鸦模型

Channels' Confirmation and Predictions' Confirmation: from the Medical Test to the Raven Paradox

Chenguang Lu

摘要:

在实证主义和证伪主义长期争论之后,普遍假设的验证被不确定的主要前提的确认所取代。不幸的是,Hemple发现了Raven Paradise(RP)。然后,卡尔纳普使用逻辑概率增量作为确认措施。到目前为止,已经提出了许多确认措施。其中Kemeny和Oppenheim提出的测度F具有Elles和Fitelson提出的对称性和不对称性,Greco等人提出的单调性,和许多研究人员提出的归一化性质。基于语义信息论,从医学测试中导出了一个类似于F的测度b*。与似然比一样,b* 和F只能表示信道质量或测试均值,而不能表示概率预测的质量。而且,使用b*、F或其他度量来澄清RP仍然不容易。因此,导出与正确率类似的度量c*。c* 具有简单的形式:(a-c)/max(a,c);它支持Nicod准则并破坏等价条件,因此可以用于消除RP。最后通过实例说明了为什么常用的确认方法难以消除反向传播。测度F、b* 和c* 表明,反例的存在越少,反例的存在就越重要,从而与波普尔的证伪思想相一致。

英文摘要:

After long arguments between positivism and falsificationism, the verification of universal hypotheses was replaced with the confirmation of uncertain major premises. Unfortunately, Hemple discovered the Raven Paradox (RP). Then, Carnap used the logical probability increment as the confirmation measure. So far, many confirmation measures have been proposed. Measure F among them proposed by Kemeny and Oppenheim possesses symmetries and asymmetries proposed by Elles and Fitelson, monotonicity proposed by Greco et al., and normalizing property suggested by many researchers. Based on the semantic information theory, a measure b* similar to F is derived from the medical test. Like the likelihood ratio, b* and F can only indicate the quality of channels or the testing means instead of the quality of probability predictions. And, it is still not easy to use b*, F, or another measure to clarify the RP. For this reason, measure c* similar to the correct rate is derived. The c* has the simple form: (a-c)/max(a, c); it supports the Nicod Criterion and undermines the Equivalence Condition, and hence, can be used to eliminate the RP. Some examples are provided to show why it is difficult to use one of popular confirmation measures to eliminate the RP. Measure F, b*, and c* indicate that fewer counterexamples' existence is more essential than more positive examples' existence, and hence, are compatible with Popper's falsification thought.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑