在Yang et al.(2017 a,b)和Yagli et al.(2019)最近的工作中,已经考虑了加利福尼亚州模拟光伏数据集的分层光伏(PV)发电的地理,时间和顺序确定性协调。在前两种情况下,分别在空间和时间域进行协调。为了进一步提高预测精度,在第三种情况下,这两种调和方法依次应用。在复制的预测实验,出现了一些问题的非负性和连贯性(在空间和/或时间)的顺序调和的预测。此外,虽然所考虑的方法在基准持久性预测的准确性提高是清晰可见的,在任何数据粒度,我们认为,一个更好的性能可以通过彻底利用跨时间层次结构。在本文中,跨时间点预测调和方法适用于生成非负的,完全一致的(在空间和时间)的预测。特别是,两步,迭代和同步跨时间协调程序之间的一些关系是第一次建立,最终协调的预测的非负性问题,正确地处理在一个简单的方式,并采用最新的跨时间协调方法。标准化的均方根误差被用来衡量预测的准确性,并进行统计多重比较程序来排名的方法。除了确保协调预测的完全一致性和非负性外,结果还表明,对于所考虑的数据集,跨时间预测协调在任何横截面层次和任何时间粒度上都显着改善了Yagli等人提出的顺序程序(2019)。
英文摘要:
In recent works by Yang et al. (2017a,b), and Yagli et al. (2019), geographical, temporal, and sequential deterministic reconciliation of hierarchical photovoltaic (PV) power generation have been considered for a simulated PV dataset in California. In the first two cases, the reconciliations are carried out in spatial and temporal domains separately. To further improve forecasting accuracy, in the third case these two reconciliation approaches are sequentially applied. During the replication of the forecasting experiment, some issues emerged about non-negativity and coherence (in space and/or in time) of the sequentially reconciled forecasts. Furthermore, while the accuracy improvement of the considered approaches over the benchmark persistence forecasts is clearly visible at any data granularity, we argue that an even better performance may be obtained by a thorough exploitation of cross-temporal hierarchies. In this paper the cross-temporal point forecast reconciliation approach is applied to generate non-negative, fully coherent (both in space and time) forecasts. In particular, some relationships between two-step, iterative and simultaneous cross-temporal reconciliation procedures are for the first time established, non-negativity issues of the final reconciled forecasts are correctly dealt with in a simple way, and the most recent cross-temporal reconciliation approaches are adopted. The normalised Root Mean Square Error is used to measure forecasting accuracy, and a statistical multiple comparison procedure is performed to rank the approaches. Besides assuring full coherence, and non-negativity of the reconciled forecasts, the results show that for the considered dataset, cross-temporal forecast reconciliation significantly improves on the sequential procedures proposed by Yagli et al. (2019), at any cross-sectional level of the hierarchy and for any temporal granularity.
Forecast combination based forecast reconciliation: insights and extensions
在最近的一篇论文中,在阐明预测组合和横截面预测协调之间的联系的同时,Hollyman等人(2021)提出了一种基于预测组合的方法来协调简单的层次结构。一个新的水平条件相干(LCC)点预测和解程序的开发,它表明,一组LCC的简单平均,自下而上的和解预测(称为组合条件相干,CCC)的结果在良好的性能相比,通过国家的最先进的横截面和解程序。在本文中,我们沿着一些新的方向建立和扩展这一建议。(1)我们揭示了LCC和解公式的性质和数学推导,表明它是一个外生线性约束的二次损失函数的最小化的结果,在目标和基础预测与对角关联矩阵之间的差异。(2)内生约束也可以考虑,导致所有相关序列的水平条件调和预测,其中上部和下部时间序列都被一致地修正。(3)由于LCC程序不保证非负的调和预测,我们认为,当非负是一个自然属性的变量进行预测-其解释为一个公正的自上而下的和解程序留下了一些疑问。(4)新的程序中使用的经典澳大利亚旅游需求(游客夜)数据集的预测实验。由于用于计算基本预测的(可能不同的)模型所发挥的关键作用,我们将Hollyman et al.(2021)的CCC调和重新解释为预测池方法,表明采用简单的预测平均策略可以提高准确性。
Robust optimal reconciliation for hierarchical time series forecasting with M-estimation
School of Economics and Management, Beihang University(北京航空航天大学经济管理学院);Data Management Department, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited(中国工商银行股份有限公司数据管理部);MOE Key Laboratory of Complex System Analysis and Management Decision, Beihang University(北京航空航天大学复杂系统分析与管理决策教育部重点实验室);Department of Mathematics, The University of Manchester(曼彻斯特大学数学系)