arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2106.05653stat.AP
收藏

基于预测组合的预测对账:见解和扩展

Forecast combination based forecast reconciliation: insights and extensions

Tommaso Di Fonzo, Daniele Girolimetto

摘要:

在最近的一篇论文中,在阐明预测组合和横截面预测协调之间的联系的同时,Hollyman等人(2021)提出了一种基于预测组合的方法来协调简单的层次结构。一个新的水平条件相干(LCC)点预测和解程序的开发,它表明,一组LCC的简单平均,自下而上的和解预测(称为组合条件相干,CCC)的结果在良好的性能相比,通过国家的最先进的横截面和解程序。在本文中,我们沿着一些新的方向建立和扩展这一建议。(1)我们揭示了LCC和解公式的性质和数学推导,表明它是一个外生线性约束的二次损失函数的最小化的结果,在目标和基础预测与对角关联矩阵之间的差异。(2)内生约束也可以考虑,导致所有相关序列的水平条件调和预测,其中上部和下部时间序列都被一致地修正。(3)由于LCC程序不保证非负的调和预测,我们认为,当非负是一个自然属性的变量进行预测-其解释为一个公正的自上而下的和解程序留下了一些疑问。(4)新的程序中使用的经典澳大利亚旅游需求(游客夜)数据集的预测实验。由于用于计算基本预测的(可能不同的)模型所发挥的关键作用,我们将Hollyman et al.(2021)的CCC调和重新解释为预测池方法,表明采用简单的预测平均策略可以提高准确性。

英文摘要:

In a recent paper, while elucidating the links between forecast combination and cross-sectional forecast reconciliation, Hollyman et al. (2021) have proposed a forecast combination-based approach to the reconciliation of a simple hierarchy. A new Level Conditional Coherent (LCC) point forecast reconciliation procedure was developed, and it was shown that the simple average of a set of LCC, and bottom-up reconciled forecasts (called Combined Conditional Coherent, CCC) results in good performance as compared to those obtained through the state-of-the-art cross-sectional reconciliation procedures. In this paper, we build upon and extend this proposal along some new directions. (1) We shed light on the nature and the mathematical derivation of the LCC reconciliation formula, showing that it is the result of an exogenously linearly constrained minimization of a quadratic loss function in the differences between the target and the base forecasts with a diagonal associated matrix. (2) Endogenous constraints may be considered as well, resulting in level conditional reconciled forecasts of all the involved series, where both the upper and the bottom time series are coherently revised. (3) As the LCC procedure does not guarantee the non-negativity of the reconciled forecasts, we argue that - when non-negativity is a natural attribute of the variables to be forecast - its interpretation as an unbiased top-down reconciliation procedure leaves room for some doubts. (4) The new procedures are used in a forecasting experiment on the classical Australian Tourism Demand (Visitor Nights) dataset. Due to the crucial role played by the (possibly different) models used to compute the base forecasts, we re-interpret the CCC reconciliation of Hollyman et al. (2021) as a forecast pooling approach, showing that accuracy improvement may be gained by adopting a simple forecast averaging strategy.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑