On the importance of measuring accurately LDOS maps using scanning tunneling spectroscopy in materials presenting atom-dependent charge order: the case of the correlated Pb/Si(111) single atomic layer
C. Tresca, T. Bilgeri, T. Bilgeri, G. Menard, V. Cherkez, R. Federicci, D. Longo, M. Hervé, F. Debontridder, P. David, D. Roditchev, G. Profeta, T. Cren, M. Calandra, C. Brun
我们展示了如何正确地提取局部电荷顺序在二维材料的扫描隧道显微镜/光谱(STM/STS)测量。当电荷序在晶胞内呈现原子尺度的空间变化并且是能量依赖的时,应特别小心。在这种情况下,锁定技术的使用,而获得一个STM拓扑在封闭的反馈回路,导致系统不正确的dI/dV测量给出一个错误的本地电荷顺序。正确的方法是执行恒定高度测量或执行dI/dV(V)光谱的全网格,使用材料带宽之外的偏置电压设定点,其中局部状态密度(LDOS)是空间均匀的。我们以1/3单层Pb/Si(111)作为二维材料的典型例子。由于该相的大面积不能生长,因此该系统中的电荷有序化不能通过角分辨光电发射或掠射X射线衍射来获得。STM/STS先前的研究补充了{ \it ab initio}密度泛函理论(DFT)计算得出的结论是,这种材料经历了相变到低温$3\times 3$重建,其中一个Pb原子向上移动,其余两个Pb原子向下移动。Adler的第三项STM/STS研究{ \it et al.} [PRL 123,086401(2019)]得出了相反的结论,即两个Pb原子向上移动,而一个Pb原子向下移动。后一个错误的结论来自于对锁定技术的滥用。相比之下,使用完整的dI/dV(V)光谱测量网格,我们表明,能量依赖的LDOS图与最先进的DFT计算非常一致,证实了一上两下电荷排序。$3\times 3$晶胞中的这种结构和电荷重新排序同样由电子-电子相互作用和与基底的耦合驱动。
英文摘要:
We show how to properly extract the local charge order in two-dimensional materials from scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy (STM/STS) measurements. When the charge order presents spatial variations at the atomic scale inside the unit cell and is energy dependent, particular care should be taken. In such cases the use of the lock-in technique, while acquiring an STM topography in closed feedback loop, leads to systematically incorrect dI/dV measurements giving a false local charge order. A correct method is either to perform a constant height measurement or to perform a full grid of dI/dV(V) spectroscopies, using a bias voltage setpoint outside the material bandwidth where the local density-of-states (LDOS) is spatially homogeneous. We take as a paradigmatic example of two-dimensional material the 1/3 single-layer Pb/Si(111). As large areas of this phase cannot be grown, charge ordering in this system is not accessible to angular resolved photoemission or grazing x-ray diffraction. Previous investigations by STM/STS supplemented by {\it ab initio} Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations concluded that this material undergoes a phase transition to a low-temperature $3\times 3$ reconstruction where one Pb atom moves up, the two remaining Pb atoms shifting down. A third STM/STS study by Adler {\it et al.} [PRL 123, 086401 (2019)] came to the opposite conclusion, i.e. that two Pb atoms move up, while one Pb atom shifts down. This latter erroneous conclusion comes from a misuse of the lock-in technique. In contrast, using a full grid of dI/dV(V) spectroscopy measurements, we show that the energy-dependent LDOS maps agree very well with state-of-the-art DFT calculations confirming the one-up two-down charge ordering. This structural and charge re-ordering in the $3\times 3$ unit cell is equally driven by electron-electron interactions and the coupling to the substrate.
STM imaging of electronic waves on the surface of Bi$_2$Te$_3$: topologically protected surface states and hexagonal warping effects
高品质的Bi $_2$ Te $_3$晶体的扫描隧道光谱研究表现出完美的对应关系的ARPES数据,从而使识别不同的制度测量的局域态密度(LDOS)。分析了LDOS在阶跃附近的振荡现象。在表面带振荡的主要部分强烈阻尼,支持拓扑保护的假设。在更高的能量,作为表面带成为凹,振荡出现分散与一个特定的波矢量,可能导致从一个非常规的六边形翘曲项。
Inferring effective interactions from the local density of states: application to STM data from Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{8+δ}$
虽然杂质对金属中的局域态密度(LDOS)的影响由于干涉效应而众所周知是非局域的,但是LDOS的低阶矩通常可以被示出为仅取决于哈密顿量的局域结构。具体而言,我们表明,这些时刻的空间变化的分析允许一个“向后工作”从扫描隧道显微镜(STM)的数据来推断当地的结构的基础有效的哈密顿量。将这种分析应用于高温超导体Bi $_2$ Sr $_2$ CaCu $_2$ O $_{8+δ}$的STM数据,我们发现电化学势的变化非常小(即,在某种意义上,无序是弱的),但是在d-波隙参数的局部幅度中存在大的变化。