被遗忘的AI伦理学边缘
The Forgotten Margins of AI Ethics
摘要:
最近的人工智能伦理文献如何在持续的社会和结构性权力不对称的背景下解决公平和正义等主题?我们追溯历史根源和当前的里程碑式的工作,一直在塑造该领域,并将这些作品分为三大类:(i)那些扎根于西方规范哲学,(ii)数学和统计方法,以及(iii)那些新兴的关键数据/算法/信息研究。我们还调查了这一领域,并通过研究属于AI伦理广泛保护伞下的快速增长的文献来探索新兴趋势。为此,我们阅读并注释了过去四年在两个主要会议上发表的同行评审论文:FAccT和AIES。我们根据三个主要方面开发的注释方案来组织文献:论文是否涉及具体的应用程序,用例和/或人们的生活经验;在多大程度上它涉及受伤害,受威胁或其他边缘化的群体;如果是这样,它是否明确命名这些群体。我们注意到,尽管大多数FAccT和AIES论文的目标往往值得称赞,但他们对人工智能对传统边缘化群体的负面影响的考虑仍然很肤浅。总之,我们的概念分析和注释论文的数据表明,该领域将受益于越来越多地关注基于具体用例,人们的经验和应用程序的伦理分析,以及对结构和历史权力不对称敏感的方法。
英文摘要:
How has recent AI Ethics literature addressed topics such as fairness and justice in the context of continued social and structural power asymmetries? We trace both the historical roots and current landmark work that have been shaping the field and categorize these works under three broad umbrellas: (i) those grounded in Western canonical philosophy, (ii) mathematical and statistical methods, and (iii) those emerging from critical data/algorithm/information studies. We also survey the field and explore emerging trends by examining the rapidly growing body of literature that falls under the broad umbrella of AI Ethics. To that end, we read and annotated peer-reviewed papers published over the past four years in two premier conferences: FAccT and AIES. We organize the literature based on an annotation scheme we developed according to three main dimensions: whether the paper deals with concrete applications, use-cases, and/or people's lived experience; to what extent it addresses harmed, threatened, or otherwise marginalized groups; and if so, whether it explicitly names such groups. We note that although the goals of the majority of FAccT and AIES papers were often commendable, their consideration of the negative impacts of AI on traditionally marginalized groups remained shallow. Taken together, our conceptual analysis and the data from annotated papers indicate that the field would benefit from an increased focus on ethical analysis grounded in concrete use-cases, people's experiences, and applications as well as from approaches that are sensitive to structural and historical power asymmetries.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。