arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2402.08171cs.CY
收藏

AI伦理劳动中的认知权力:为情境化诉求赋予合法性

Epistemic Power in AI Ethics Labor: Legitimizing Located Complaints

David Gray Widder

AI总结:

本文通过75名技术从业者访谈,揭示主流AI伦理实践依赖量化获取合法性却边缘化具身经验的问题,结合多领域女性主义理论分析其影响,并提出明确认知局限、消解权力层级的谦逊技术实践。

摘要:

什么才算合法的AI伦理劳动?相应地,AI伦理主张是基于哪些认知条件获得合法性的?本文基于对75名技术从业者(包括研究者、开发者、开源贡献者和活动家)的访谈,探讨了人们讨论和实践AI伦理的各类认知基础。在外界将AI伦理抨击为“进步”阻碍的背景下,本文揭示了部分AI伦理实践如何借助自动化与量化获取权威,并因此获得了一定合法性,而那些基于丰富具身性和情境化生活经验的实践却未能如此。本文结合女性主义人类学与科学技术研究学者Diana Forsythe、Lucy Suchman的研究,以及后殖民女性主义理论家Sara Ahmed和黑人女性主义理论家Kristie Dotson的著作,考察了主流AI伦理实践的影响。\n主流AI伦理实践(采用Model Cards(模型卡)及类似干预手段)通过巩固量化的认知权力,在赋予AI伦理项目合法性的同时,也在同等程度上将具身生活经验边缘化,使其无法成为该项目的合法组成部分。对此,本文提出谦逊技术实践:这类量化或技术实践专门致力于明确自身的认知局限,以消解认知权力的层级结构。

英文摘要:

What counts as legitimate AI ethics labor, and consequently, what are the epistemic terms on which AI ethics claims are rendered legitimate? Based on 75 interviews with technologists including researchers, developers, open source contributors, and activists, this paper explores the various epistemic bases from which AI ethics is discussed and practiced. In the context of outside attacks on AI ethics as an impediment to "progress," I show how some AI ethics practices have reached toward authority from automation and quantification, and achieved some legitimacy as a result, while those based on richly embodied and situated lived experience have not. This paper draws together the work of feminist Anthropology and Science and Technology Studies scholars Diana Forsythe and Lucy Suchman with the works of postcolonial feminist theorist Sara Ahmed and Black feminist theorist Kristie Dotson to examine the implications of dominant AI ethics practices. By entrenching the epistemic power of quantification, dominant AI ethics practices -- employing Model Cards and similar interventions -- risk legitimizing AI ethics as a project in equal and opposite measure to which they marginalize embodied lived experience as a legitimate part of the same project. In response, I propose humble technical practices: quantified or technical practices which specifically seek to make their epistemic limits clear in order to flatten hierarchies of epistemic power.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑