arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2104.04103stat.MLcs.LG
收藏

因果决策和因果效应估计是不一样的。and Why It Matters

Causal Decision Making and Causal Effect Estimation Are Not the Same... and Why It Matters

HKUST(香港科技大学);NYU(纽约大学);Compass Inc.(Compass公司)

Carlos Fernández-Loría, Foster Provost

摘要:

基于机器学习的因果决策(CDM)已经成为商业的常规部分。企业在算法上有针对性地提供优惠、激励和建议,以影响消费者的行为。最近,我们看到了与CDM和使用机器学习模型的因果效应估计(CEE)相关的研究的加速。本文强调了一个重要的观点:CDM与CEE不同,并且与直觉相反,准确的CEE对于准确的CDM来说是不必要的。我们的经验是,这不是很好地理解从业者或大多数研究人员。从技术上讲,感兴趣的被估量是不同的,这对清洁发展机制的建模和统计模型的使用都有重要的影响。我们借鉴以前的研究,强调三个影响。(1)我们应该仔细考虑因果机器学习的目标函数,如果可能的话,优化准确的治疗分配,而不是准确的效应量估计。(2)混淆对CDM的影响与对CEE的影响不同。结果是,为了支持CDM,使用混杂数据和使用非混杂数据学习可能一样好,甚至更好。最后,(3)因果统计建模可能不是支持CDM所必需的,因为统计建模的代理目标可能做得一样好或更好。这第三个观察有助于解释至少一种乍一看似乎是错误的普遍的CDM做法:广泛使用非因果模型来确定干预措施。最后两个含义在实践中特别重要,因为获取所有反事实的(无混杂)数据可能成本高昂,而且往往不切实际。这些发现开辟了大量的研究领域。我们希望通过指出来自多个贡献领域的相关文章,包括过去三到四年发表的二十多篇文章,来促进这一领域的研究。

英文摘要:

Causal decision making (CDM) based on machine learning has become a routine part of business. Businesses algorithmically target offers, incentives, and recommendations to affect consumer behavior. Recently, we have seen an acceleration of research related to CDM and causal effect estimation (CEE) using machine-learned models. This article highlights an important perspective: CDM is not the same as CEE, and counterintuitively, accurate CEE is not necessary for accurate CDM. Our experience is that this is not well understood by practitioners or most researchers. Technically, the estimand of interest is different, and this has important implications both for modeling and for the use of statistical models for CDM. We draw on prior research to highlight three implications. (1) We should consider carefully the objective function of the causal machine learning, and if possible, optimize for accurate treatment assignment rather than for accurate effect-size estimation. (2) Confounding does not have the same effect on CDM as it does on CEE. The upshot is that for supporting CDM it may be just as good or even better to learn with confounded data as with unconfounded data. Finally, (3) causal statistical modeling may not be necessary to support CDM because a proxy target for statistical modeling might do as well or better. This third observation helps to explain at least one broad common CDM practice that seems wrong at first blush: the widespread use of non-causal models for targeting interventions. The last two implications are particularly important in practice, as acquiring (unconfounded) data on all counterfactuals can be costly and often impracticable. These observations open substantial research ground. We hope to facilitate research in this area by pointing to related articles from multiple contributing fields, including two dozen articles published the last three to four years.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑