arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2103.13287cs.CYcs.CRcs.HC
收藏

安全研究中的人为因素:2008-2018年的经验教训

Human Factors in Security Research: Lessons Learned from 2008-2018

Mannat Kaur, Michel van Eeten, Marijn Janssen, Kevin Borgolte, Tobias Fiebig

摘要:

计算机安全研究现在不仅考虑技术,还努力通过研究普通用户以及在较小程度上研究系统操作员和开发人员等专家来考虑人为因素。我们把我们的分析集中在对专家的关键人群的研究上,他们的人为错误可以同时影响许多系统,并将其与对普通用户的研究进行比较。为了了解我们在人为因素领域的进展,该领域如何进一步成熟,并为该领域的新研究人员提供参考,我们分析了过去十年在安全和隐私方面的人为因素研究,确定了557篇相关出版物。其中,我们发现了48篇专注于专家用户的出版物,并对其进行了深入分析。为了获得更多的见解,我们将它们与48项最终用户研究的分层样本进行了比较。在本文中,我们调查:(i)对人的因素的看法,以及我们如何从安全科学中学习(ii)如何招募参与者以及招募谁,以及我们发现这如何创建以西方为中心的观点(iii)研究目标,以及如何将这些与所选择的研究方法相结合(iv)如何使用理论来提高社区科学工作的严谨性,包括对扎根理论的使用的限制,这往往是不完全应用(v)研究人员如何处理伦理影响,以及我们可以做些什么来更一致地解释它们虽然我们的文献综述有局限性,但新的见解被揭示,并为进一步的研究确定了途径。

英文摘要:

Instead of only considering technology, computer security research now strives to also take into account the human factor by studying regular users and, to a lesser extent, experts like operators and developers of systems. We focus our analysis on the research on the crucial population of experts, whose human errors can impact many systems at once, and compare it to research on regular users. To understand how far we advanced in the area of human factors, how the field can further mature, and to provide a point of reference for researchers new to this field, we analyzed the past decade of human factors research in security and privacy, identifying 557 relevant publications. Of these, we found 48 publications focused on expert users and analyzed all in depth. For additional insights, we compare them to a stratified sample of 48 end-user studies. In this paper we investigate: (i) The perspective on human factors, and how we can learn from safety science (ii) How and who are the participants recruited, and how this -- as we find -- creates a western-centric perspective (iii) Research objectives, and how to align these with the chosen research methods (iv) How theories can be used to increase rigor in the communities scientific work, including limitations to the use of Grounded Theory, which is often incompletely applied (v) How researchers handle ethical implications, and what we can do to account for them more consistently Although our literature review has limitations, new insights were revealed and avenues for further research identified.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑