arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2102.04527cs.HCcs.AIcs.CY
收藏

与机器人玩责备游戏

Playing the Blame Game with Robots

University of Zurich(苏黎世大学);University of Tübingen(图宾根大学);Digital Society Initiative (University of Zurich)(数字社会倡议(苏黎世大学));University of Geneva(日内瓦大学)

Markus Kneer, Michael T. Stuart

摘要:

最近的研究表明-有点令人不安-当人工智能驱动的系统造成伤害时,人们愿意将道德责任归咎于它们[1]-[4]。在本文中,我们探讨了这些发现的道德心理基础。我们的假设是,人们将道德责任归咎于人工智能系统的原因是,他们认为人工智能系统能够娱乐灌输的精神状态(法律上称为犯罪意图)。为了探索这一假设,我们创建了一个场景,在这个场景中,人工智能系统通过使用一种新型肥料来冒着毒害人类的风险。在受试者间设计中操纵人工智能系统的计算(或准认知)能力,我们测试了人们是否愿意将伤害的重大风险归因于知识(即,鲁莽)并归咎于AI系统。此外,我们还调查了对AI系统的鲁莽和指责是否会影响系统用户(或所有者)的感知责任。在一项有347名参与者的实验中,我们发现(i)人们愿意在鲁莽的情况下将责任归咎于人工智能系统,(ii)责任归因强烈依赖于归因于鲁莽的意愿,(iii)后者反过来取决于系统的感知“认知”能力。此外,我们的研究结果表明(iv)AI系统的计算复杂度越高,从人类用户转移到AI系统的责任就越多。

英文摘要:

Recent research shows -- somewhat astonishingly -- that people are willing to ascribe moral blame to AI-driven systems when they cause harm [1]-[4]. In this paper, we explore the moral-psychological underpinnings of these findings. Our hypothesis was that the reason why people ascribe moral blame to AI systems is that they consider them capable of entertaining inculpating mental states (what is called mens rea in the law). To explore this hypothesis, we created a scenario in which an AI system runs a risk of poisoning people by using a novel type of fertilizer. Manipulating the computational (or quasi-cognitive) abilities of the AI system in a between-subjects design, we tested whether people's willingness to ascribe knowledge of a substantial risk of harm (i.e., recklessness) and blame to the AI system. Furthermore, we investigated whether the ascription of recklessness and blame to the AI system would influence the perceived blameworthiness of the system's user (or owner). In an experiment with 347 participants, we found (i) that people are willing to ascribe blame to AI systems in contexts of recklessness, (ii) that blame ascriptions depend strongly on the willingness to attribute recklessness and (iii) that the latter, in turn, depends on the perceived "cognitive" capacities of the system. Furthermore, our results suggest (iv) that the higher the computational sophistication of the AI system, the more blame is shifted from the human user to the AI system.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑