arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2011.03016cs.SE
收藏

软件开发过程中的伦理:从行为准则到伦理审议

Ethics in the Software Development Process: From Codes of Conduct to Ethical Deliberation

Jan Gogoll, Niina Zuber, Severin Kacianka, Timo Greger, Alexander Pretschner, Julian Nida-Rümelin

摘要:

软件系统在我们的生活中扮演着越来越重要的角色,软件工程师和他们的公司发现自己处于一个对可能出现的道德问题负责的位置。在本文中,我们试图解开那些属于更广泛的领域的商业道德,可以在软件工程师的水平进行的道德考虑。处理属于工程师责任的道德问题,传统上是通过出版《道德和行为守则》来解决的。我们认为,这些代码是勉强能够提供规范的方向,在软件开发。本文的主要贡献是,因此,分析规范的特点,道德守则在软件工程,并阐明如何以价值为基础的方法可能会阻止其实用性从规范的角度来看。行为守则不能取代道德审议,因为它们没有也不能提供指导,因为它们的性质不够明确。我们认为,这种缺乏方向感会引发反应性行为,如“摘樱桃”、“漠不关心的风险”、“事后导向”和“依赖直觉的愿望”。有鉴于此,我们建议在软件开发团队中实施道德审议作为出路。

英文摘要:

Software systems play an ever more important role in our lives and software engineers and their companies find themselves in a position where they are held responsible for ethical issues that may arise. In this paper, we try to disentangle ethical considerations that can be performed at the level of the software engineer from those that belong in the wider domain of business ethics. The handling of ethical problems that fall into the responsibility of the engineer have traditionally been addressed by the publication of Codes of Ethics and Conduct. We argue that these Codes are barely able to provide normative orientation in software development. The main contribution of this paper is, thus, to analyze the normative features of Codes of Ethics in software engineering and to explicate how their value-based approach might prevent their usefulness from a normative perspective. Codes of Conduct cannot replace ethical deliberation because they do not and cannot offer guidance because of their underdetermined nature. This lack of orientation, we argue, triggers reactive behavior such as "cherry-picking", "risk of indifference", "ex-post orientation" and the "desire to rely on gut feeling". In the light of this, we propose to implement ethical deliberation within software development teams as a way out.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑