arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2602.17426cs.SE
收藏

自适应系统中伦理的运行维度

The Runtime Dimension of Ethics in Self-Adaptive Systems

University of L’Aquila(拉奎拉大学);Gran Sasso Science Institute(格兰萨索科学研究所)

Marco Autili, Gianluca Filippone, Mashal Afzal Memon, Patrizio Pelliccione

AI总结:

本文提出自适应系统应采用运行时伦理推理,以应对伦理偏好变化、冲突及多方面协商需求,强调伦理协商在管理多主体伦理权衡中的重要性。

摘要:

自适应系统越来越多地与人类密切互动,往往共享相同的物理或虚拟环境,并在运行时做出具有伦理影响的决策。当前的方法通常将伦理编码为固定的、基于规则的约束或作为在设计时选择的单一伦理理论。这忽略了人类-系统互动设置的一个基本属性:伦理偏好因个体和群体而异,随着上下文而演变,并可能冲突,同时仍需在法律和监管定义的硬伦理框架内(例如安全和合规约束)运行。本文主张从静态的伦理规则转向自适应系统的运行时伦理推理,其中伦理偏好被视为运行时需求,必须在利益相关者和情境变化时进行获取、表示和持续修订。我们认为满足这些需求需要明确的基于伦理的协商,以管理多个与系统互动、被系统代表或受系统影响的人之间的伦理权衡。我们识别了关键挑战、伦理不确定性、伦理价值观之间的冲突(包括人类、社会和环境驱动因素),以及多维/多方/多驱动因素的协商,并概述了向伦理自适应系统的研究方向和问题。

英文摘要:

Self-adaptive systems increasingly operate in close interaction with humans, often sharing the same physical or virtual environments and making decisions with ethical implications at runtime. Current approaches typically encode ethics as fixed, rule-based constraints or as a single chosen ethical theory embedded at design time. This overlooks a fundamental property of human-system interaction settings: ethical preferences vary across individuals and groups, evolve with context, and may conflict, while still needing to remain within a legally and regulatorily defined hard-ethics envelope (e.g., safety and compliance constraints). This paper advocates a shift from static ethical rules to runtime ethical reasoning for self-adaptive systems, where ethical preferences are treated as runtime requirements that must be elicited, represented, and continuously revised as stakeholders and situations change. We argue that satisfying such requirements demands explicit ethics-based negotiation to manage ethical trade-offs among multiple humans who interact with, are represented by, or are affected by a system. We identify key challenges, ethical uncertainty, conflicts among ethical values (including human, societal, and environmental drivers), and multi-dimensional/multi-party/multi-driver negotiation, and outline research directions and questions toward ethically self-adaptive systems.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑