arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2008.12513math.HO
收藏

柏拉图《泰阿泰德篇》(147 d1- d6)中提奥多罗斯的教训--一种新的视角

Theodorus' lesson in Plato's Theaetetus (147d1-d6) Revisited-A New Perspective

Luc Brisson, Salomon Ofman

摘要:

本文是对柏拉图《泰阿泰德篇》(147 d-148 b)中所谓的“数学部分”进行研究的第一部分。这个“数学部分”的主题是非理性,这是早期希腊数学中最重要的主题之一。由于数学家、数学史学家和哲学史学家对柏拉图的研究兴趣浓厚,因此对柏拉图的研究如雪片般倾泻而下。在我们的工作中,我们重新审视了这个问题,因为我们认为缺少了一些东西:从历史、数学和哲学三个角度同时对柏拉图的文本进行全面分析。这就是我们通过一种新的翻译,一种关于无理量的数学课的新的解释,以及从这三个观点对整个段落的新的解释所承担的任务。我们的指导方针是认真对待柏拉图的著作,而不是把它当作儿戏。这个简单的规则确实令人惊讶地具有约束力,但它使我们能够对前欧几里德数学进行罕见的直接一瞥,这与数学史和哲学史上盛行的“主要标准解释”相矛盾。本研究报告因编辑原因分为两部分。在本文中,我们提出了一个分析的第一部分,这个“数学部分”,西奥多罗斯的教训。在第二篇文章(Brisson-Ofman(即将出现))中,我们呈现了课程的续集以及在整个对话框架内对“数学部分”的哲学解释。这两篇文章是一个整体。它们都是针对没有任何特定数学背景的观众,只需要基本的数学知识,基本上是高中水平。不过,附录中还阐述了一些更微妙的问题。

英文摘要:

This article is the first part of a study of the so-called 'mathematical part' of Plato's Theaetetus (147d-148b). The subject of this 'mathematical part' is the irrationality, one of the most important topics in early Greek mathematics. As of huge interest for mathematicians, historians of mathematics as well as of philosophy, there had been an avalanche of studies about it. In our work, we revisit this question, for we think something is missing: a global analysis of Plato's text, from these three points of view simultaneously: history, mathematics and philosophy. It is what we have undertook through a new translation, a new interpretation of the mathematical lesson about irrational magnitudes and a novel interpretation of the whole passage from these three points of view. Our guideline is considering Plato's writings seriously, not as some playful work. This simple rule is indeed surprisingly constraining, but it allows us to get a rare direct glance inside pre-Euclidean mathematics, in contradiction with the 'Main Standard Interpretation' prevailing in history of mathematics as well as in history of philosophy. This study had been divided in two parts for editorial reasons. In the present article, we propose an analysis of the first part of this 'mathematical part', Theodorus' lesson. In the second article (Brisson-Ofman (to appear)), we present the sequel of the lesson and a philosophical interpretation of the 'mathematical part' within the framework of the entire dialogue. Both articles form a whole. They are both aimed to an audience without any particular mathematical background, and require only elementary mathematical knowledge, essentially of high school-level. Some more delicate points are nevertheless developed in the Appendices.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑