arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1408.2326math.HO
收藏

理解柏拉图的数学理论(147 d-148 b)

Comprendre les mathématiques pour comprendre Platon - théétète (147d-148b)

Salomon Ofman

摘要:

在本文中,我们研究了柏拉图的泰阿泰德斯所谓的“数学部分”。它的主题涉及某些数量的不可否认性,用现代术语来说,就是整数的平方根的合理性或非合理性问题。作为最古老的文本对这个问题,并对希腊数学和数学家以及,其历史重要性是巨大的。理解它的困难在于我们在其中发现的不同领域的紧密交织:哲学,历史和数学。但反过来说,正确理解,它提供了一些证据,无论是关于起源的问题,无理数在希腊数学和一些点有关柏拉图的思想。考虑到历史背景和哲学背景一般遗忘在数学分析,我们得到一个新的解释,这一文本,这远远不是一个赞扬一些数学家,是一个激进的批评他们的思维方式。这堂数学课,远不是对未来数学成就的赞扬,而是以一种与整个对话一致的空洞结束。

英文摘要:

In this paper, we study the so-called 'Mathematical part' of Plato's Theaetetus. Its subject concerns the incommensurability of certain magnitudes, in modern terms the question of the rationality or irrationality of the square roots of integers. As the most ancient text on the subject, and on Greek mathematics and mathematicians as well, its historical importance is enormous. The difficulty to understand it lies in the close intertwining of different fields we found in it: philosophy, history and mathematics. But conversely, correctly understood, it gives some evidences both about the question of the origins of the irrationals in Greek mathematics and some points concerning Plato's thought. Taking into account the historical context and the philosophical background generally forgotten in mathematical analyses, we get a new interpretation of this text, which far from being a tribute to some mathematicians, is a radical criticism of their ways of thinking. And the mathematical lesson, far from being a tribute to some future mathematical achievements, is ending on an aporia, in accordance with the whole dialogue.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑