arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2008.12517math.HO
收藏

真理与知识:泰阿泰德对“权力”的错误定义--对泰阿泰德(147 d 7 - 148 b2)的新解读

Truth and Knowledge: the Incorrect Definition of `Powers' by Theaetetus-A New Interpretation of Theaetetus (147d7-148b2)

Luc Brisson, Salomon Ofman

摘要:

在第一篇文章(这里称为B-O)中,我们研究了柏拉图的Theaetetus的所谓“数学部分”的第一部分,即Theodorus的教训。在本章中,我们将考虑这段经文的续篇和结尾(147 d 7 - 148 b2),以及与整个对话有关的哲学解释。正如在前一篇文章中,我们分析它同时从数学,历史和哲学的角度来看,理解它的必要性。我们的策略是再次认真对待柏拉图的文本,而不是作为一个诗人的梦想。我们的分析投下了新的光在这段话,作为一个重要的证明,柏拉图的哲学和数学史。柏拉图与狄奥多罗斯和泰阿泰德的关系比通常所说的要复杂得多;在对话的大部分甚至在其他一些对话中,对知识定义的探索都植根于数学段落;它需要重新评估它与欧几里得几何原本的联系,特别是命题X.9,还有一个所谓的欧几里德的“灾难性”错误(引用让·伊塔德的话)。简而言之,这段经文必须以不同于通常的解释来理解,这些解释聚集在一起,统称为“现代标准解释”(MSI)。这两篇文章是一个整体。它们都是针对没有任何特定数学背景的观众,只需要基本的数学知识,基本上是高中水平。一些更复杂的观点在文章末尾的附录中阐述。

英文摘要:

In a first article (referred here as B-O), we studied the first part of the so-called 'mathematical part' of Plato's Theaetetus, i.e. Theodorus' lesson. In the present one, we consider the sequel and the end of the passage (147d7-148b2), as well as its philosophical interpretation in connection with the whole dialogue. As in the previous article, we analyze it simultaneously from the mathematical, the historical and the philosophical points of view, a necessity to understand it. Our strategy is once again to take seriously Plato's text, not as the dream of a poet. Our analysis casts a new light on this passage, as an essential testimony for both Plato's philosophy and for history of mathematics. Plato's relation to Theodorus and Theaetetus is more complex than usually claimed; the search for a definition of knowledge conducted in a large part of the dialogue and even in some other dialogues is rooted in the mathematical passage; it needs a reevaluation of its connection to Euclid's Elements, in particular the proposition X.9, as well as a supposed Euclid's 'catastrophic' mistake (to quote Jean Itard) on incommensurability. In a nutshell, the passage has to be understood differently than in the usual interpretations gathered together under the collective so-called name 'Modern Standard Interpretation' (or MSI). Both articles form a whole. They are both aimed to an audience without any particular mathematical background, and require only elementary mathematical knowledge, essentially of high school-level. Some more complex points are developed in an Appendix at the end of the article.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑