In this paper we perform an experimental comparison of three different target based 3D-LIDAR camera calibration algorithms. We briefly elucidate the mathematical background behind each method and provide insights into practical aspects like ease of data collection for all of them. We extensively evaluate these algorithms on a sensor suite which consists multiple cameras and LIDARs by assessing their robustness to random initialization and by using metrics like Mean Line Re-projection Error (MLRE) and Factory Stereo Calibration Error. We also show the effect of noisy sensor on the calibration result from all the algorithms and conclude with a note on which calibration algorithm should be used under what circumstances.
Determining the extrinsic parameter between multiple LiDARs and cameras is essential for autonomous robots, especially for solid-state LiDARs, where each LiDAR unit has a very small Field-of-View (FoV), and multiple units are often used collectively. The majority of extrinsic calibration methods are proposed for 360$^\circ$ mechanical spinning LiDARs where the FoV overlap with other LiDAR or camera sensors is assumed. Few research works have been focused on the calibration of small FoV LiDARs and cameras nor on the improvement of the calibration speed. In this work, we consider the problem of …
Accurate and reliable sensor calibration is critical for fusing LiDAR and inertial measurements in autonomous driving. This paper proposes a novel three-stage extrinsic calibration method between LiDAR and GNSS/INS for autonomous driving. The first stage can quickly calibrate the extrinsic parameters between the sensors through point cloud surface features so that the extrinsic can be narrowed from a large initial error to a small error range in little time. The second stage can further calibrate the extrinsic parameters based on LiDAR-mapping space occupancy while removing motion distortion. …
Sensor-based environmental perception is a crucial step for autonomous driving systems, for which an accurate calibration between multiple sensors plays a critical role. For the calibration of LiDAR and camera, the existing method is generally to calibrate the intrinsic of the camera first and then calibrate the extrinsic of the LiDAR and camera. If the camera's intrinsic is not calibrated correctly in the first stage, it isn't easy to calibrate the LiDAR-camera extrinsic accurately. Due to the complex internal structure of the camera and the lack of an effective quantitative evaluation method…
In this work we present a novel method to jointly calibrate a sensor suite consisting a 3D-LiDAR, Inertial Measurement Unit (IMU) and Camera under an Extended Kalman Filter (EKF) framework. We exploit pairwise constraints between the 3 sensor pairs to perform EKF update and experimentally demonstrate the superior performance obtained with joint calibration as against individual sensor pair calibration.
Texas A&M University（德克萨斯农工大学）；Ford Motor Company（福特汽车公司）
This work presents an extrinsic parameter estimation algorithm between a 3D LIDAR and a Projective Camera using a marker-less planar target, by exploiting Planar Surface Point to Plane and Planar Edge Point to back-projected Plane geometric constraints. The proposed method uses the data collected by placing the planar board at different poses in the common field of view of the LIDAR and the Camera. The steps include, detection of the target and the edges of the target in LIDAR and Camera frames, matching the detected planes and lines across both the sensing modalities and finally solving a cos…
Accurate LiDAR-camera extrinsic calibration is a precondition for many multi-sensor systems in mobile robots. Most calibration methods rely on laborious manual operations and calibration targets. While working online, the calibration methods should be able to extract information from the environment to construct the cross-modal data association. Convolutional neural networks (CNNs) have powerful feature extraction ability and have been used for calibration. However, most of the past methods solve the extrinsic as a regression task, without considering the geometric constraints involved. In thi…
Texas A&M University（得克萨斯农工大学）；Ford Motor Company（福特汽车公司）
This work presents a novel target-free extrinsic calibration algorithm for a 3D Lidar and an IMU pair using an Extended Kalman Filter (EKF) which exploits the \textit{motion based calibration constraint} for state update. The steps include, data collection by motion excitation of the Lidar Inertial Sensor suite along all degrees of freedom, determination of the inter sensor rotation by using rotational component of the aforementioned \textit{motion based calibration constraint} in a least squares optimization framework, and finally, the determination of inter sensor translation using the \text…
The University of Hong Kong（香港大学）；Southern University of Science and Technology（南方科技大学）
In this letter, we present a novel method for automatic extrinsic calibration of high-resolution LiDARs and RGB cameras in targetless environments. Our approach does not require checkerboards but can achieve pixel-level accuracy by aligning natural edge features in the two sensors. On the theory level, we analyze the constraints imposed by edge features and the sensitivity of calibration accuracy with respect to edge distribution in the scene. On the implementation level, we carefully investigate the physical measuring principles of LiDARs and propose an efficient and accurate LiDAR edge extra…
National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology（产业技术综合研究所）
This paper presents an open source LiDAR-camera calibration toolbox that is general to LiDAR and camera projection models, requires only one pairing of LiDAR and camera data without a calibration target, and is fully automatic. For automatic initial guess estimation, we employ the SuperGlue image matching pipeline to find 2D-3D correspondences between LiDAR and camera data and estimate the LiDAR-camera transformation via RANSAC. Given the initial guess, we refine the transformation estimate with direct LiDAR-camera registration based on the normalized information distance, a mutual information…
Joint Optimization-based Targetless Extrinsic Calibration for Multiple LiDARs and GNSS-Aided INS of Ground Vehicles
Institute of Systems Engineering and Collaborative Laboratory for Intelligent Science and Systems, Macau University of Science and Technology（系统工程研究院和智能科学与系统联合实验室，澳门科学技术大学）；Institute for AI Industry Research (AIR), Tsinghua University（人工智能产业研究院（AIR），清华大学）
For most LiDAR-inertial odometry, accurate initial states, including temporal offset and extrinsic transformation between LiDAR and 6-axis IMUs, play a significant role and are often considered as prerequisites. However, such information may not be always available in customized LiDAR-inertial systems. In this paper, we propose LI-Init: a full and real-time LiDAR-inertial system initialization process that calibrates the temporal offset and extrinsic parameter between LiDARs and IMUs, and also the gravity vector and IMU bias by aligning the state estimated from LiDAR measurements with that mea…
The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology（香港科技大学）；Huawei Technologies（华为技术有限公司）
Extrinsic perturbation always exists in multiple sensors. In this paper, we focus on the extrinsic uncertainty in multi-LiDAR systems for 3D object detection. We first analyze the influence of extrinsic perturbation on geometric tasks with two basic examples. To minimize the detrimental effect of extrinsic perturbation, we propagate an uncertainty prior on each point of input point clouds, and use this information to boost an approach for 3D geometric tasks. Then we extend our findings to propose a multi-LiDAR 3D object detector called MLOD. MLOD is a two-stage network where the multi-LiDAR in…
Zhejiang University（浙江大学）；University of Delaware（特拉华大学）；Huzhou Institute of Zhejiang University（浙江大学湖州研究院）
Accurate and reliable sensor calibration is essential to fuse LiDAR and inertial measurements, which are usually available in robotic applications. In this paper, we propose a novel LiDAR-IMU calibration method within the continuous-time batch-optimization framework, where the intrinsics of both sensors and the spatial-temporal extrinsics between sensors are calibrated without using calibration infrastructure such as fiducial tags. Compared to discrete-time approaches, the continuous-time formulation has natural advantages for fusing high rate measurements from LiDAR and IMU sensors. To improv…
MFCalib: Single-shot and Automatic Extrinsic Calibration for LiDAR and Camera in Targetless Environments Based on Multi-Feature Edge
College of Mechatronics and Control Engineering, Shenzhen University（深圳大学机电与控制工程学院）；Peng Cheng Laboratory（鹏城实验室）；Manifold Tech Limited（万孚科技有限公司）；The University of Hong Kong（香港大学）
As neuromorphic technology is maturing, its application to robotics and autonomous vehicle systems has become an area of active research. In particular, event cameras have emerged as a compelling alternative to frame-based cameras in low-power and latency-demanding applications. To enable event cameras to operate alongside staple sensors like lidar in perception tasks, we propose a direct, temporally-decoupled extrinsic calibration method between event cameras and lidars. The high dynamic range, high temporal resolution, and low-latency operation of event cameras are exploited to directly regi…
The University of Tokyo（东京大学）；Southeast University（东南大学）
Recently, multi-sensors fusion has achieved significant progress in the field of automobility to improve navigation and position performance. As the prerequisite of the fusion algorithm, the demand for the extrinsic calibration of multi-sensors is growing. To calculate the extrinsic parameter, many researches have been dedicated to the two-step method, which integrates the respective calibration in pairs. It is inefficient and incompact because of losing sight of the constrain of all sensors. With regard to remove this burden, an optimization-based IMU/Lidar/Camera co-calibration method is pro…
GMMCalib: Extrinsic Calibration of LiDAR Sensors using GMM-based Joint Registration
Technical University of Munich（慕尼黑工业大学）；TUM School of Engineering and Design（慕尼黑工业大学工程与设计学院）；TUM School of Computation, Information and Technology（慕尼黑工业大学计算、信息与技术学院）
Native-Domain Cross-Attention for Camera-LiDAR Extrinsic Calibration Under Large Initial Perturbations
School of Automation, Beijing Institute of Technology（北京理工大学自动化学院）；School of Integrated Circuits and Electronics, Beijing Institute of Technology（北京理工大学集成电路与电子学院）
Australian Centre for Field Robotics（澳大利亚野外机器人学中心）；University of Sydney（悉尼大学）
This paper proposes an automated method to obtain the extrinsic calibration parameters between a camera and a 3D lidar with as low as 16 beams. We use a checkerboard as a reference to obtain features of interest in both sensor frames. The calibration board centre point and normal vector are automatically extracted from the lidar point cloud by exploiting the geometry of the board. The corresponding features in the camera image are obtained from the camera's extrinsic matrix. We explain the reasons behind selecting these features, and why they are more robust compared to other possibilities. To…
Hong Kong University of Science and Technology（香港科技大学）
Combining multiple LiDARs enables a robot to maximize its perceptual awareness of environments and obtain sufficient measurements, which is promising for simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM). This paper proposes a system to achieve robust and simultaneous extrinsic calibration, odometry, and mapping for multiple LiDARs. Our approach starts with measurement preprocessing to extract edge and planar features from raw measurements. After a motion and extrinsic initialization procedure, a sliding window-based multi-LiDAR odometry runs onboard to estimate poses with online calibration refine…
Accurate depth-sensing plays a crucial role in securing a high success rate of robotic harvesting in natural orchard environments. Solid-state LiDAR (SSL), a recently introduced LiDAR technique, can perceive high-resolution geometric information of the scenes, which can be potential utilised to receive accurate depth information. Meanwhile, the fusion of the sensory information from LiDAR and camera can significantly enhance the sensing ability of the harvesting robots. This work introduces a LiDAR-camera fusion-based visual sensing and perception strategy to perform accurate fruit localisatio…
YOCO: You Only Calibrate Once for Accurate Extrinsic Parameter in LiDAR-Camera Systems
China University of Mining and Technology (Beijing)（中国矿业大学（北京））；College of Geoscience and Surveying Engineering, China University of Mining and Technology (Beijing)（中国矿业大学（北京）地球科学与测绘工程学院）
The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (Guangzhou)（香港科技大学（广州））；Hong Kong University of Science and Technology（香港科技大学）；HKUST Shenzhen-Hong Kong Collaborative Innovation Research Institute（香港科技大学深港协同创新研究院）；CWB Institute of Autonomous Driving（CWB自动驾驶研究院）
The combination of LiDARs and cameras enables a mobile robot to perceive environments with multi-modal data, becoming a key factor in achieving robust perception. Traditional frame cameras are sensitive to changing illumination conditions, motivating us to introduce novel event cameras to make LiDAR-camera fusion more complete and robust. However, to jointly exploit these sensors, the challenging extrinsic calibration problem should be addressed. This paper proposes an automatic checkerboard-based approach to calibrate extrinsics between a LiDAR and a frame/event camera, where four contributio…
This paper presents a framework for the targetless extrinsic calibration of stereo cameras and Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR) sensors with a non-overlapping Field of View (FOV). In order to solve the extrinsic calibrations problem under such challenging configuration, the proposed solution exploits road markings as static and robust features among the various dynamic objects that are present in urban environment. First, this study utilizes road markings that are commonly captured by the two sensor modalities to select informative images for estimating the extrinsic parameters. In order to…
A Target-based Multi-LiDAR Multi-Camera Extrinsic Calibration System
Research \& Development, Toyota Material Handling Manufacturing, Bologna Italy Department of Information Engineering, University of Pisa, Pisa, Italy School of Engineering；Materials Science, Queen Mary University of London, London, United Kingdom
For an autonomous vehicle, the ability to sense its surroundings and to build an overall representation of the environment by fusing different sensor data streams is fundamental. To this end, the poses of all sensors need to be accurately determined. Traditional calibration methods are based on: 1) using targets specifically designed for calibration purposes in controlled environments, 2) optimizing a quality metric of the point clouds collected while traversing an unknown but static environment, or 3) optimizing the match among per-sensor incremental motion observations along a motion path fu…
As an essential procedure of data fusion, LiDAR-camera calibration is critical for autonomous vehicles and robot navigation. Most calibration methods rely on hand-crafted features and require significant amounts of extracted features or specific calibration targets. With the development of deep learning (DL) techniques, some attempts take advantage of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to regress the 6 degrees of freedom (DOF) extrinsic parameters. Nevertheless, the performance of these DL-based methods is reported to be worse than the non-DL methods. This paper proposed an online LiDAR-came…
Sensor setups consisting of a combination of 3D range scanner lasers and stereo vision systems are becoming a popular choice for on-board perception systems in vehicles; however, the combined use of both sources of information implies a tedious calibration process. We present a method for extrinsic calibration of lidar-stereo camera pairs without user intervention. Our calibration approach is aimed to cope with the constraints commonly found in automotive setups, such as low-resolution and specific sensor poses. To demonstrate the performance of our method, we also introduce a novel approach f…
L2Calib: $SE(3)$-Manifold Reinforcement Learning for Robust Extrinsic Calibration with Degenerate Motion Resilience
Institute of Cyber-Systems and Control, Zhejiang University, China（浙江大学控制科学与工程学院）；State Key Laboratory of Industrial Control Technology, Zhejiang University, China（浙江大学工业控制技术状态重点实验室）；Zhejiang Guozi Robotics Technology Co., Ltd.（浙江国智机器人科技有限公司）
The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology（香港科技大学）
Stereo cameras and dense stereo matching algorithms are core components for many robotic applications due to their abilities to directly obtain dense depth measurements and their robustness against changes in lighting conditions. However, the performance of dense depth estimation relies heavily on accurate stereo extrinsic calibration. In this work, we present a real-time markerless approach for obtaining high-precision stereo extrinsic calibration using a novel 5-DOF (degrees-of-freedom) and nonlinear optimization on a manifold, which captures the observability property of vision-only stereo …
The integration of multiple cameras and 3D Li- DARs has become basic configuration of augmented reality devices, robotics, and autonomous vehicles. The calibration of multi-modal sensors is crucial for a system to properly function, but it remains tedious and impractical for mass production. Moreover, most devices require re-calibration after usage for certain period of time. In this paper, we propose a single-shot solution for calibrating extrinsic transformations among multiple cameras and 3D LiDARs. We establish a panoramic infrastructure, in which a camera or LiDAR can be robustly localize…
Institute of Cyber-Systems and Control, Zhejiang University（浙江大学工业控制研究所）
Sensor calibration is the fundamental block for a multi-sensor fusion system. This paper presents an accurate and repeatable LiDAR-IMU calibration method (termed LI-Calib), to calibrate the 6-DOF extrinsic transformation between the 3D LiDAR and the Inertial Measurement Unit (IMU). % Regarding the high data capture rate for LiDAR and IMU sensors, LI-Calib adopts a continuous-time trajectory formulation based on B-Spline, which is more suitable for fusing high-rate or asynchronous measurements than discrete-time based approaches. % Additionally, LI-Calib decomposes the space into cells and iden…
Accurate Measurement of 3D and 2D Circular Centers With Application to LiDAR-Camera Extrinsic Calibration
Thrust of Robotics and Autonomous Systems, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (Guangzhou)（机器人与自主系统研究所，香港科技大学（广州））；Lower Airspace Economy Research Institute, International Digital Economy Academy, ShenZhen（空域经济研究所，国际数字经济学院）；Horizon-Continental Technology Corporation（Horizon-Continental技术公司）；State Key Laboratory of Rail Traffic Control and Safety and the Beijing Engineering Research Center of EMC and GNSS Technology for Rail Transportation, School of Electronic and Information Engineering, Beijing Jiaotong University（轨道交通控制与安全国家重点实验室，北京交通大学电子信息工程学院，电磁兼容与GNSS技术轨道交通工程研究中心）
This paper presents a novel method for fully automatic and convenient extrinsic calibration of a 3D LiDAR and a panoramic camera with a normally printed chessboard. The proposed method is based on the 3D corner estimation of the chessboard from the sparse point cloud generated by one frame scan of the LiDAR. To estimate the corners, we formulate a full-scale model of the chessboard and fit it to the segmented 3D points of the chessboard. The model is fitted by optimizing the cost function under constraints of correlation between the reflectance intensity of laser and the color of the chessboar…
University of Toronto Institute for Aerospace Studies（多伦多大学航空航天研究所）；University of Zagreb Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Computing（萨格勒布大学电气工程与计算学院）；Vector Institute（Vector研究所）
Reliable operation in inclement weather is essential to the deployment of safe autonomous vehicles (AVs). Robustness and reliability can be achieved by fusing data from the standard AV sensor suite (i.e., lidars, cameras) with weather robust sensors, such as millimetre-wavelength radar. Critically, accurate sensor data fusion requires knowledge of the rigid-body transform between sensor pairs, which can be determined through the process of extrinsic calibration. A number of extrinsic calibration algorithms have been designed for 2D (planar) radar sensors - however, recently-developed, low-cost…
