Deep clustering (DC) has become the state-of-the-art for unsupervised clustering. In principle, DC represents a variety of unsupervised methods that jointly learn the underlying clusters and the latent representation directly from unstructured datasets. However, DC methods are generally poorly applied due to high operational costs, low scalability, and unstable results. In this paper, we first evaluate several popular DC variants in the context of industrial applicability using eight empirical criteria. We then choose to focus on variational deep clustering (VDC) methods, since they mostly meet those criteria except for simplicity, scalability, and stability. To address these three unmet criteria, we introduce four generic algorithmic improvements: initial $γ$-training, periodic $β$-annealing, mini-batch GMM (Gaussian mixture model) initialization, and inverse min-max transform. We also propose a novel clustering algorithm S3VDC (simple, scalable, and stable VDC) that incorporates all those improvements. Our experiments show that S3VDC outperforms the state-of-the-art on both benchmark tasks and a large unstructured industrial dataset without any ground truth label. In addition, we analytically evaluate the usability and interpretability of S3VDC.
Generalized additive models (GAMs) are a widely used class of models of interest to statisticians as they provide a flexible way to design interpretable models of data beyond linear models. We here propose a scalable and well-calibrated Bayesian treatment of GAMs using Gaussian processes (GPs) and leveraging recent advances in variational inference. We use sparse GPs to represent each component and exploit the additive structure of the model to efficiently represent a Gaussian a posteriori coupling between the components.
This paper represents a preliminary (pre-reviewing) version of a sublinear variational algorithm for isotropic Gaussian mixture models (GMMs). Further developments of the algorithm for GMMs with diagonal covariance matrices (instead of isotropic clusters) and their corresponding benchmarking results have been published by TPAMI (doi:10.1109/TPAMI.2021.3133763) in the paper "A Variational EM Acceleration for Efficient Clustering at Very Large Scales". We kindly refer the reader to the TPAMI paper instead of this much earlier arXiv version (the TPAMI paper is also open access). Publicly availabl…
University of Toronto（多伦多大学）；Vector Institute（向量研究所）；Microsoft Research New England（微软新英格兰研究院）；New York University（纽约大学）
We introduce a new scalable variational Gaussian process approximation which provides a high fidelity approximation while retaining general applicability. We propose the harmonic kernel decomposition (HKD), which uses Fourier series to decompose a kernel as a sum of orthogonal kernels. Our variational approximation exploits this orthogonality to enable a large number of inducing points at a low computational cost. We demonstrate that, on a range of regression and classification problems, our approach can exploit input space symmetries such as translations and reflections, and it significantly …
ETH Zürich（苏黎世联邦理工学院）；University of Cambridge（剑桥大学）；University of Warwick（华威大学）；University of California, Irvine（加州大学欧文分校）
Conventional variational autoencoders fail in modeling correlations between data points due to their use of factorized priors. Amortized Gaussian process inference through GP-VAEs has led to significant improvements in this regard, but is still inhibited by the intrinsic complexity of exact GP inference. We improve the scalability of these methods through principled sparse inference approaches. We propose a new scalable GP-VAE model that outperforms existing approaches in terms of runtime and memory footprint, is easy to implement, and allows for joint end-to-end optimization of all components…
ETH Zürich（苏黎世联邦理工学院）；Human Technopole（人类技术园）；University Hospital Basel（巴塞尔大学医院）；University Children’s Hospital Basel（巴塞尔大学儿童医院）；University of Zürich（苏黎世大学）；Politecnico di Milano（米兰理工大学）；St. Gallen Cantonal Hospital（圣加仑州立医院）
In this work, we study the problem of clustering survival data $-$ a challenging and so far under-explored task. We introduce a novel semi-supervised probabilistic approach to cluster survival data by leveraging recent advances in stochastic gradient variational inference. In contrast to previous work, our proposed method employs a deep generative model to uncover the underlying distribution of both the explanatory variables and censored survival times. We compare our model to the related work on clustering and mixture models for survival data in comprehensive experiments on a wide range of sy…
University of Utah（犹他大学）；School of Computing（计算学院）；Scientific Computing and Imaging Institute（科学计算与成像研究所）
Gaussian process regression networks (GPRN) are powerful Bayesian models for multi-output regression, but their inference is intractable. To address this issue, existing methods use a fully factorized structure (or a mixture of such structures) over all the outputs and latent functions for posterior approximation, which, however, can miss the strong posterior dependencies among the latent variables and hurt the inference quality. In addition, the updates of the variational parameters are inefficient and can be prohibitively expensive for a large number of outputs. To overcome these limitations…
Gaussian process classification is a popular method with a number of appealing properties. We show how to scale the model within a variational inducing point framework, outperforming the state of the art on benchmark datasets. Importantly, the variational formulation can be exploited to allow classification in problems with millions of data points, as we demonstrate in experiments.
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign（伊利诺伊大学厄巴纳-香槟分校）
Semidefinite programming (SDP) is a powerful tool for tackling a wide range of computationally hard problems such as clustering. Despite the high accuracy, semidefinite programs are often too slow in practice with poor scalability on large (or even moderate) datasets. In this paper, we introduce a linear time complexity algorithm for approximating an SDP relaxed $K$-means clustering. The proposed sketch-and-lift (SL) approach solves an SDP on a subsampled dataset and then propagates the solution to all data points by a nearest-centroid rounding procedure. It is shown that the SL approach enjoy…
Duke University（杜克大学）；University of Minnesota-Twin Cities（明尼苏达大学双城分校）
Motivated by the ever-increasing demands for limited communication bandwidth and low-power consumption, we propose a new methodology, named joint Variational Autoencoders with Bernoulli mixture models (VAB), for performing clustering in the compressed data domain. The idea is to reduce the data dimension by Variational Autoencoders (VAEs) and group data representations by Bernoulli mixture models (BMMs). Once jointly trained for compression and clustering, the model can be decomposed into two parts: a data vendor that encodes the raw data into compressed data, and a data consumer that classifi…
We implement gradient-based variational inference routines for Wishart and inverse Wishart processes, which we apply as Bayesian models for the dynamic, heteroskedastic covariance matrix of a multivariate time series. The Wishart and inverse Wishart processes are constructed from i.i.d. Gaussian processes, existing variational inference algorithms for which form the basis of our approach. These methods are easy to implement as a black-box and scale favorably with the length of the time series, however, they fail in the case of the Wishart process, an issue we resolve with a simple modification…
One iteration of standard $k$-means (i.e., Lloyd's algorithm) or standard EM for Gaussian mixture models (GMMs) scales linearly with the number of clusters $C$, data points $N$, and data dimensionality $D$. In this study, we explore whether one iteration of $k$-means or EM for GMMs can scale sublinearly with $C$ at run-time, while improving the clustering objective remains effective. The tool we apply for complexity reduction is variational EM, which is typically used to make training of generative models with exponentially many hidden states tractable. Here, we apply novel theoretical results…
Data Science Institute, University of Technology Sydney（悉尼科技大学数据科学研究所）；School of Information Technology, Deakin University（迪肯大学信息技术学院）；School of Computer Science and Engineering, University of New South Wales（新南威尔士大学计算机科学与工程学院）；School of Computer Science, University of Technology Sydney（悉尼科技大学计算机科学学院）
Recent works for attributed network clustering utilize graph convolution to obtain node embeddings and simultaneously perform clustering assignments on the embedding space. It is effective since graph convolution combines the structural and attributive information for node embedding learning. However, a major limitation of such works is that the graph convolution only incorporates the attribute information from the local neighborhood of nodes but fails to exploit the mutual affinities between nodes and attributes. In this regard, we propose a variational co-embedding learning model for attribu…
University of Oxford（牛津大学）；University of Cambridge（剑桥大学）；University College London（伦敦大学学院）；Health Data Research UK（英国健康数据研究中心）；The Alan Turing Institute（艾伦·图灵研究所）；University of Manchester（曼彻斯特大学）
Work in deep clustering focuses on finding a single partition of data. However, high-dimensional data, such as images, typically feature multiple interesting characteristics one could cluster over. For example, images of objects against a background could be clustered over the shape of the object and separately by the colour of the background. In this paper, we introduce Multi-Facet Clustering Variational Autoencoders (MFCVAE), a novel class of variational autoencoders with a hierarchy of latent variables, each with a Mixture-of-Gaussians prior, that learns multiple clusterings simultaneously,…
VICatMix: variational Bayesian clustering and variable selection for discrete biomedical data
MRC Biostatistics Unit University of Cambridge East Forvie Building（医学研究理事会生物统计学单位剑桥大学东部大楼）；MRC Biostatistics Unit and CRUK Cambridge Centre Ovarian Programme and Cambridge Institute of Therapeutic Immunology and Infectious Disease (CITIID) University of Cambridge（医学研究理事会生物统计学单位和癌症研究英国委员会剑桥中心卵巢计划及剑桥治疗免疫学和传染病研究所（CITIID）剑桥大学）
The Cut posterior and related Semi-Modular Inference are Generalised Bayes methods for Modular Bayesian evidence combination. Analysis is broken up over modular sub-models of the joint posterior distribution. Model-misspecification in multi-modular models can be hard to fix by model elaboration alone and the Cut posterior and SMI offer a way round this. Information entering the analysis from misspecified modules is controlled by an influence parameter $η$ related to the learning rate. This paper contains two substantial new methods. First, we give variational methods for approximating the Cut …
Stanford University（斯坦福大学）；Facebook AI Research（Facebook人工智能研究院）；University of California, Los Angeles（加州大学洛杉矶分校）
A structural equation model (SEM) is an effective framework to reason over causal relationships represented via a directed acyclic graph (DAG). Recent advances have enabled effective maximum-likelihood point estimation of DAGs from observational data. However, a point estimate may not accurately capture the uncertainty in inferring the underlying graph in practical scenarios, wherein the true DAG is non-identifiable and/or the observed dataset is limited. We propose Bayesian Causal Discovery Nets (BCD Nets), a variational inference framework for estimating a distribution over DAGs characterizi…
In this paper, a scale mixture of Normal distributions model is developed for classification and clustering of data having outliers and missing values. The classification method, based on a mixture model, focuses on the introduction of latent variables that gives us the possibility to handle sensitivity of model to outliers and to allow a less restrictive modelling of missing data. Inference is processed through a Variational Bayesian Approximation and a Bayesian treatment is adopted for model learning, supervised classification and clustering.
We develop a scalable multi-step Monte Carlo algorithm for inference under a large class of nonparametric Bayesian models for clustering and classification. Each step is "embarrassingly parallel" and can be implemented using the same Markov chain Monte Carlo sampler. The simplicity and generality of our approach makes inference for a wide range of Bayesian nonparametric mixture models applicable to large datasets. Specifically, we apply the approach to inference under a product partition model with regression on covariates. We show results for inference with two motivating data sets: a large s…
Scalable Dirichlet Process Mixture Models with Unknown Concentration and Adaptive Covariance for High-Dimensional Clustering Applied to Leukemia Transcriptomics
Several structure-learning algorithms for staged trees, asymmetric extensions of Bayesian networks, have been proposed. However, these either do not scale efficiently as the number of variables considered increases, a priori restrict the set of models, or they do not find comparable models to existing methods. Here, we define an alternative algorithm based on a totally ordered hyperstage. We demonstrate how it can be used to obtain a quadratically-scaling structural learning algorithm for staged trees that restricts the model space a-posteriori. Through comparative analysis, we show that throu…
We propose to compute Wasserstein barycenters (WBs) by solving for Monge maps with variational principle. We discuss the metric properties of WBs and explore their connections, especially the connections of Monge WBs, to K-means clustering and co-clustering. We also discuss the feasibility of Monge WBs on unbalanced measures and spherical domains. We propose two new problems -- regularized K-means and Wasserstein barycenter compression. We demonstrate the use of VWBs in solving these clustering-related problems.
We propose a general variational framework of fair clustering, which integrates an original Kullback-Leibler (KL) fairness term with a large class of clustering objectives, including prototype or graph based. Fundamentally different from the existing combinatorial and spectral solutions, our variational multi-term approach enables to control the trade-off levels between the fairness and clustering objectives. We derive a general tight upper bound based on a concave-convex decomposition of our fairness term, its Lipschitz-gradient property and the Pinsker's inequality. Our tight upper bound can…
The main contribution of the paper is a new approach to subspace clustering that is significantly more computationally efficient and scalable than existing state-of-the-art methods. The central idea is to modify the regression technique in sparse subspace clustering (SSC) by replacing the $\ell_1$ minimization with a generalization called Ordered Weighted $\ell_1$ (OWL) minimization which performs simultaneous regression and clustering of correlated variables. Using random geometric graph theory, we prove that OWL regression selects more points within each subspace, resulting in better cluster…
South China Agricultural University（华南农业大学）；Nanyang Technological University（南洋理工大学）；Sun Yat-sen University（中山大学）；Nanchang University（南昌大学）
This paper focuses on scalability and robustness of spectral clustering for extremely large-scale datasets with limited resources. Two novel algorithms are proposed, namely, ultra-scalable spectral clustering (U-SPEC) and ultra-scalable ensemble clustering (U-SENC). In U-SPEC, a hybrid representative selection strategy and a fast approximation method for K-nearest representatives are proposed for the construction of a sparse affinity sub-matrix. By interpreting the sparse sub-matrix as a bipartite graph, the transfer cut is then utilized to efficiently partition the graph and obtain the cluste…
University College of London（伦敦大学学院）；Athens University of Economics and Business（雅典经济与商业大学）；The Alan Turing Institute（艾伦·图灵研究所）
We present a scalable approach to performing approximate fully Bayesian inference in generic state space models. The proposed method is an alternative to particle MCMC that provides fully Bayesian inference of both the dynamic latent states and the static parameters of the model. We build up on recent advances in computational statistics that combine variational methods with sequential Monte Carlo sampling and we demonstrate the advantages of performing full Bayesian inference over the static parameters rather than just performing variational EM approximations. We illustrate how our approach e…
ETH Zürich（苏黎世联邦理工学院）；Life Science Graduate School Zurich（苏黎世生命科学研究生院）；Swiss Institute of Bioinformatics（瑞士生物信息学研究所）；University of Tübingen（图宾根大学）
Clustering high-dimensional data, such as images or biological measurements, is a long-standingproblem and has been studied extensively. Recently, Deep Clustering has gained popularity due toits flexibility in fitting the specific peculiarities of complex data. Here we introduce the Mixture-of-Experts Similarity Variational Autoencoder (MoE-Sim-VAE), a novel generative clustering model.The model can learn multi-modal distributions of high-dimensional data and use these to generaterealistic data with high efficacy and efficiency. MoE-Sim-VAE is based on a Variational Autoencoder(VAE), where the…
Amirkabir University of Technology（阿米拉比尔理工大学）；University of Twente（特温特大学）；ICAR-CNR（意大利国家研究委员会计算与高性能网络研究所）
This paper presents a batch-wise density-based clustering approach for local outlier detection in massive-scale datasets. Unlike the well-known traditional algorithms, which assume that all the data is memory-resident, our proposed method is scalable and processes the input data chunk-by-chunk within the confines of a limited memory buffer. A temporary clustering model is built at the first phase; then, it is gradually updated by analyzing consecutive memory loads of points. Subsequently, at the end of scalable clustering, the approximate structure of the original clusters is obtained. Finally…
Discrete random variables are natural components of probabilistic clustering models. A number of VAE variants with discrete latent variables have been developed. Training such methods requires marginalizing over the discrete latent variables, causing training time complexity to be linear in the number clusters. By applying a continuous relaxation to the discrete variables in these methods we can achieve a reduction in the training time complexity to be constant in the number of clusters used. We demonstrate that in practice for one such method, the Gaussian Mixture VAE, the use of a continuous…
We study in this paper a variant of Wasserstein barycenter problem, which we refer to as tree-Wasserstein barycenter, by leveraging a specific class of ground metrics, namely tree metrics, for Wasserstein distance. Drawing on the tree structure, we propose an efficient algorithmic approach to solve the tree-Wasserstein barycenter and its variants. The proposed approach is not only fast for computation but also efficient for memory usage. Exploiting the tree-Wasserstein barycenter and its variants, we scale up multi-level clustering and scalable Bayes, especially for large-scale applications wh…
Faculty of Information Technology, University of Jyvaskyla（于韦斯屈莱大学信息技术学院）
In this work, two new initialization methods for K-means clustering are proposed. Both proposals are based on applying a divide-and-conquer approach for the K-means|| type of an initialization strategy. The second proposal also utilizes multiple lower-dimensional subspaces produced by the random projection method for the initialization. The proposed methods are scalable and can be run in parallel, which make them suitable for initializing large-scale problems. In the experiments, comparison of the proposed methods to the K-means++ and K-means|| methods is conducted using an extensive set of re…
We propose a simple and easy to implement neural network compression algorithm that achieves results competitive with more complicated state-of-the-art methods. The key idea is to modify the original optimization problem by adding K independent Gaussian priors (corresponding to the k-means objective) over the network parameters to achieve parameter quantization, as well as an L1 penalty to achieve pruning. Unlike many existing quantization-based methods, our method uses hard clustering assignments of network parameters, which adds minimal change or overhead to standard network training. We als…
Department of Statistical Science, Duke University（杜克大学统计科学系）；Departments of Computational Medicine, Statistics, and Human Genetics, UCLA（加州大学洛杉矶分校计算医学、统计与人类遗传学系）
Clustering, a fundamental activity in unsupervised learning, is notoriously difficult when the feature space is high-dimensional. Fortunately, in many realistic scenarios, only a handful of features are relevant in distinguishing clusters. This has motivated the development of sparse clustering techniques that typically rely on k-means within outer algorithms of high computational complexity. Current techniques also require careful tuning of shrinkage parameters, further limiting their scalability. In this paper, we propose a novel framework for sparse k-means clustering that is intuitive, sim…
FISHDBC is a flexible, incremental, scalable, and hierarchical density-based clustering algorithm. It is flexible because it empowers users to work on arbitrary data, skipping the feature extraction step that usually transforms raw data in numeric arrays letting users define an arbitrary distance function instead. It is incremental and scalable: it avoids the $\mathcal O(n^2)$ performance of other approaches in non-metric spaces and requires only lightweight computation to update the clustering when few items are added. It is hierarchical: it produces a "flat" clustering which can be expanded …
We develop a data driven approach to perform clustering and end-to-end feature learning simultaneously for streaming data that can adaptively detect novel clusters in emerging data. Our approach, Adaptive Nonparametric Variational Autoencoder (AdapVAE), learns the cluster membership through a Bayesian Nonparametric (BNP) modeling framework with Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) for feature learning. We develop a joint online variational inference algorithm to learn feature representations and clustering assignments simultaneously via iteratively optimizing the Evidence Lower Bound (ELBO). We resolve…
Kogakuin University of Technology and Engineering（工学院大学）
Finite mixture models, typically Gaussian mixtures, are well known and widely used as model-based clustering. In practical situations, there are many non-Gaussian data that are heavy-tailed and/or asymmetric. Normal inverse Gaussian (NIG) distributions are normal-variance mean which mixing densities are inverse Gaussian distributions and can be used for both haavy-tail and asymmetry. For NIG mixture models, both expectation-maximization method and variational Bayesian (VB) algorithms have been proposed. However, the existing VB algorithm for NIG mixture have a disadvantage that the shape of th…
IBM Research AI（IBM研究院人工智能部门）；Carnegie Mellon University（卡内基梅隆大学）；College of William and Mary（威廉与玛丽学院）；Huawei Research（华为研究院）
Spectral clustering is one of the most effective clustering approaches that capture hidden cluster structures in the data. However, it does not scale well to large-scale problems due to its quadratic complexity in constructing similarity graphs and computing subsequent eigendecomposition. Although a number of methods have been proposed to accelerate spectral clustering, most of them compromise considerable information loss in the original data for reducing computational bottlenecks. In this paper, we present a novel scalable spectral clustering method using Random Binning features (RB) to simu…
Variational inference has had great success in scaling approximate Bayesian inference to big data by exploiting mini-batch training. To date, however, this strategy has been most applicable to models of independent data. We propose an extension to state space models of time series data based on a novel generative model for latent temporal states: the neural moving average model. This permits a subsequence to be sampled without drawing from the entire distribution, enabling training iterations to use mini-batches of the time series at low computational cost. We illustrate our method on autoregr…
University of Massachusetts Amherst（马萨诸塞大学阿默斯特分校）；Microsoft Research（微软研究院）；IBM（国际商业机器公司）
We introduce Grinch, a new algorithm for large-scale, non-greedy hierarchical clustering with general linkage functions that compute arbitrary similarity between two point sets. The key components of Grinch are its rotate and graft subroutines that efficiently reconfigure the hierarchy as new points arrive, supporting discovery of clusters with complex structure. Grinch is motivated by a new notion of separability for clustering with linkage functions: we prove that when the model is consistent with a ground-truth clustering, Grinch is guaranteed to produce a cluster tree containing the ground…
DBSCAN is a classical density-based clustering procedure with tremendous practical relevance. However, DBSCAN implicitly needs to compute the empirical density for each sample point, leading to a quadratic worst-case time complexity, which is too slow on large datasets. We propose DBSCAN++, a simple modification of DBSCAN which only requires computing the densities for a chosen subset of points. We show empirically that, compared to traditional DBSCAN, DBSCAN++ can provide not only competitive performance but also added robustness in the bandwidth hyperparameter while taking a fraction of the …
University of Oxford（牛津大学）；Alan Turing Institute（艾伦·图灵研究所）；University of Birmingham（伯明翰大学）；University of Manchester（曼彻斯特大学）
Variational Autoencoders (VAEs) provide a flexible and scalable framework for non-linear dimensionality reduction. However, in application domains such as genomics where data sets are typically tabular and high-dimensional, a black-box approach to dimensionality reduction does not provide sufficient insights. Common data analysis workflows additionally use clustering techniques to identify groups of similar features. This usually leads to a two-stage process, however, it would be desirable to construct a joint modelling framework for simultaneous dimensionality reduction and clustering of feat…
Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio de Janeiro (PUC-Rio)（里约热内卢天主教大学）
Minimum sum-of-squares clustering (MSSC) is a widely used clustering model, of which the popular K-means algorithm constitutes a local minimizer. It is well known that the solutions of K-means can be arbitrarily distant from the true MSSC global optimum, and dozens of alternative heuristics have been proposed for this problem. However, no other algorithm has been predominantly adopted in the literature. This may be related to differences of computational effort, or to the assumption that a near-optimal solution of the MSSC has only a marginal impact on clustering validity. In this article, we …
In this paper, we develop an unsupervised generative clustering framework that combines the Variational Information Bottleneck and the Gaussian Mixture Model. Specifically, in our approach, we use the Variational Information Bottleneck method and model the latent space as a mixture of Gaussians. We derive a bound on the cost function of our model that generalizes the Evidence Lower Bound (ELBO) and provide a variational inference type algorithm that allows computing it. In the algorithm, the coders' mappings are parametrized using neural networks, and the bound is approximated by Monte Carlo s…
Scalable Mean-Field Variational Inference via Preconditioned Primal-Dual Optimization
Department of Industrial Engineering and Management Science, Northwestern University（工业工程与管理科学系，西北大学）；Department of Mathematics, Northwestern University（数学系，西北大学）；Department of Biostatistics, Brown University（生物统计学系，布朗大学）
We study a variant of the variational autoencoder model (VAE) with a Gaussian mixture as a prior distribution, with the goal of performing unsupervised clustering through deep generative models. We observe that the known problem of over-regularisation that has been shown to arise in regular VAEs also manifests itself in our model and leads to cluster degeneracy. We show that a heuristic called minimum information constraint that has been shown to mitigate this effect in VAEs can also be applied to improve unsupervised clustering performance with our model. Furthermore we analyse the effect of …
The University of Melbourne（墨尔本大学）；Deakin University（迪肯大学）；Data61, CSIRO（联邦科学与工业研究组织Data61）
Subspace clustering aims to find groups of similar objects (clusters) that exist in lower dimensional subspaces from a high dimensional dataset. It has a wide range of applications, such as analysing high dimensional sensor data or DNA sequences. However, existing algorithms have limitations in finding clusters in non-disjoint subspaces and scaling to large data, which impinge their applicability in areas such as bioinformatics and the Internet of Things. We aim to address such limitations by proposing a subspace clustering algorithm using a bottom-up strategy. Our algorithm first searches for…
Stevens Institute of Technology（斯蒂文斯理工学院）；Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute（伦斯勒理工学院）；International Computer Science Institute（国际计算机科学研究所）；University of California at Berkeley（加州大学伯克利分校）
Kernel $k$-means clustering can correctly identify and extract a far more varied collection of cluster structures than the linear $k$-means clustering algorithm. However, kernel $k$-means clustering is computationally expensive when the non-linear feature map is high-dimensional and there are many input points. Kernel approximation, e.g., the Nyström method, has been applied in previous works to approximately solve kernel learning problems when both of the above conditions are present. This work analyzes the application of this paradigm to kernel $k$-means clustering, and shows that applying t…
