University of Maryland（马里兰大学）；University of Massachusetts Amherst（马萨诸塞大学阿默斯特分校）；University of California Berkeley（加州大学伯克利分校）；Technion - Israel Institute of Technology（以色列理工学院）
Saba Ahmadi, Sainyam Galhotra, Barna Saha, Roy Schwartz
In this paper we study the problem of correlation clustering under fairness constraints. In the classic correlation clustering problem, we are given a complete graph where each edge is labeled positive or negative. The goal is to obtain a clustering of the vertices that minimizes disagreements -- the number of negative edges trapped inside a cluster plus positive edges between different clusters.
We consider two variations of fairness constraint for the problem of correlation clustering where each node has a color, and the goal is to form clusters that do not over-represent vertices of any color.
The first variant aims to generate clusters with minimum disagreements, where the distribution of a feature (e.g. gender) in each cluster is same as the global distribution. For the case of two colors when the desired ratio of the number of colors in each cluster is $1:p$, we get $\mathcal{O}(p^2)$-approximation algorithm. Our algorithm could be extended to the case of multiple colors. We prove this problem is NP-hard.
The second variant considers relative upper and lower bounds on the number of nodes of any color in a cluster. The goal is to avoid violating upper and lower bounds corresponding to each color in each cluster while minimizing the total number of disagreements. Along with our theoretical results, we show the effectiveness of our algorithm to generate fair clusters by empirical evaluation on real world data sets.
In this paper, we study correlation clustering under fairness constraints. Fair variants of $k$-median and $k$-center clustering have been studied recently, and approximation algorithms using a notion called fairlet decomposition have been proposed. We obtain approximation algorithms for fair correlation clustering under several important types of fairness constraints. Our results hinge on obtaining a fairlet decomposition for correlation clustering by introducing a novel combinatorial optimization problem. We define a fairlet decomposition with cost similar to the $k$-median cost and this all…
Given the widespread popularity of spectral clustering (SC) for partitioning graph data, we study a version of constrained SC in which we try to incorporate the fairness notion proposed by Chierichetti et al. (2017). According to this notion, a clustering is fair if every demographic group is approximately proportionally represented in each cluster. To this end, we develop variants of both normalized and unnormalized constrained SC and show that they help find fairer clusterings on both synthetic and real data. We also provide a rigorous theoretical analysis of our algorithms on a natural vari…
Google（谷歌）；University of Maryland（马里兰大学）；Carnegie Mellon University（卡内基梅隆大学）
As machine learning has become more prevalent, researchers have begun to recognize the necessity of ensuring machine learning systems are fair. Recently, there has been an interest in defining a notion of fairness that mitigates over-representation in traditional clustering. In this paper we extend this notion to hierarchical clustering, where the goal is to recursively partition the data to optimize a specific objective. For various natural objectives, we obtain simple, efficient algorithms to find a provably good fair hierarchical clustering. Empirically, we show that our algorithms can find…
Toyota Technological Institute at Chicago（芝加哥丰田理工学院）；University of Wisconsin-Madison（威斯康星大学麦迪逊分校）
We give a local search based algorithm for $k$-median and $k$-means (and more generally for any $k$-clustering with $\ell_p$ norm cost function) from the perspective of individual fairness. More precisely, for a point $x$ in a point set $P$ of size $n$, let $r(x)$ be the minimum radius such that the ball of radius $r(x)$ centered at $x$ has at least $n/k$ points from $P$. Intuitively, if a set of $k$ random points are chosen from $P$ as centers, every point $x\in P$ expects to have a center within radius $r(x)$. An individually fair clustering provides such a guarantee for every point $x\in P$…
University of Maryland（马里兰大学）；Wellesley College（韦尔斯利学院）；Carnegie Mellon University（卡内基梅隆大学）；Northwestern University（西北大学）
Clustering is a foundational problem in machine learning with numerous applications. As machine learning increases in ubiquity as a backend for automated systems, concerns about fairness arise. Much of the current literature on fairness deals with discrimination against protected classes in supervised learning (group fairness). We define a different notion of fair clustering wherein the probability that two points (or a community of points) become separated is bounded by an increasing function of their pairwise distance (or community diameter). We capture the situation where data points repres…
What does it mean for a clustering to be fair? One popular approach seeks to ensure that each cluster contains groups in (roughly) the same proportion in which they exist in the population. The normative principle at play is balance: any cluster might act as a representative of the data, and thus should reflect its diversity. But clustering also captures a different form of representativeness. A core principle in most clustering problems is that a cluster center should be representative of the cluster it represents, by being "close" to the points associated with it. This is so that we can effe…
Fair clustering is the process of grouping similar entities together, while satisfying a mathematically well-defined fairness metric as a constraint. Due to the practical challenges in precise model specification, the prescribed fairness constraints are often incomplete and act as proxies to the intended fairness requirement, leading to biased outcomes when the system is deployed. We examine how to identify the intended fairness constraint for a problem based on limited demonstrations from an expert. Each demonstration is a clustering over a subset of the data. We present an algorithm to ident…
IIT Kharagpur（印度理工学院卡哈拉格普尔分校）；University of California, Santa Barbara（加州大学圣巴巴拉分校）；MPI-SWS（马克斯·普朗克软件系统研究所）；Rice University（莱斯大学）
Ensuring fairness in machine learning algorithms is a challenging and essential task. We consider the problem of clustering a set of points while satisfying fairness constraints. While there have been several attempts to capture group fairness in the $k$-clustering problem, fairness at an individual level is relatively less explored. We introduce a new notion of individual fairness in $k$-clustering based on features not necessarily used for clustering. We show that this problem is NP-hard and does not admit a constant factor approximation. Therefore, we design a randomized algorithm that guar…
Department of Computer Science, Duke University（计算机科学系，杜克大学）
We extend the fair machine learning literature by considering the problem of proportional centroid clustering in a metric context. For clustering $n$ points with $k$ centers, we define fairness as proportionality to mean that any $n/k$ points are entitled to form their own cluster if there is another center that is closer in distance for all $n/k$ points. We seek clustering solutions to which there are no such justified complaints from any subsets of agents, without assuming any a priori notion of protected subsets. We present and analyze algorithms to efficiently compute, optimize, and audit …
We study fair clustering problems as proposed by Chierichetti et al. (NIPS 2017). Here, points have a sensitive attribute and all clusters in the solution are required to be balanced with respect to it (to counteract any form of data-inherent bias). Previous algorithms for fair clustering do not scale well. We show how to model and compute so-called coresets for fair clustering problems, which can be used to significantly reduce the input data size. We prove that the coresets are composable and show how to compute them in a streaming setting. Furthermore, we propose a variant of Lloyd's algori…
In data summarization we want to choose $k$ prototypes in order to summarize a data set. We study a setting where the data set comprises several demographic groups and we are restricted to choose $k_i$ prototypes belonging to group $i$. A common approach to the problem without the fairness constraint is to optimize a centroid-based clustering objective such as $k$-center. A natural extension then is to incorporate the fairness constraint into the clustering problem. Existing algorithms for doing so run in time super-quadratic in the size of the data set, which is in contrast to the standard $k…
Correlation clustering is a ubiquitous paradigm in unsupervised machine learning where addressing unfairness is a major challenge. Motivated by this, we study Fair Correlation Clustering where the data points may belong to different protected groups and the goal is to ensure fair representation of all groups across clusters. Our paper significantly generalizes and improves on the quality guarantees of previous work of Ahmadi et al. and Ahmadian et al. as follows. - We allow the user to specify an arbitrary upper bound on the representation of each group in a cluster. - Our algorithm allows ind…
Indian Institute of Science（印度科学学院）；University of Maryland, College Park（马里兰大学帕克分校）；Microsoft Research（微软研究院）
Center-based clustering (e.g., $k$-means, $k$-medians) and clustering using linear subspaces are two most popular techniques to partition real-world data into smaller clusters. However, when the data consists of sensitive demographic groups, significantly different clustering cost per point for different sensitive groups can lead to fairness-related harms (e.g., different quality-of-service). The goal of socially fair clustering is to minimize the maximum cost of clustering per point over all groups. In this work, we propose a unified framework to solve socially fair center-based clustering an…
University of Maryland（马里兰大学）；Wellesley College（韦尔斯利学院）
Clustering is a fundamental unsupervised learning problem where a dataset is partitioned into clusters that consist of nearby points in a metric space. A recent variant, fair clustering, associates a color with each point representing its group membership and requires that each color has (approximately) equal representation in each cluster to satisfy group fairness. In this model, the cost of the clustering objective increases due to enforcing fairness in the algorithm. The relative increase in the cost, the ''price of fairness,'' can indeed be unbounded. Therefore, in this paper we propose to…
Fair clustering is a constrained variant of clustering where the goal is to partition a set of colored points, such that the fraction of points of any color in every cluster is more or less equal to the fraction of points of this color in the dataset. This variant was recently introduced by Chierichetti et al. [NeurIPS, 2017] in a seminal work and became widely popular in the clustering literature. In this paper, we propose a new construction of coresets for fair clustering based on random sampling. The new construction allows us to obtain the first coreset for fair clustering in general metri…
Toyota Technological Institute at Chicago（芝加哥丰田技术研究所）；Technical University of Dortmund（多特蒙德工业大学）
We consider the $k$-clustering problem with $\ell_p$-norm cost, which includes $k$-median, $k$-means and $k$-center, under an individual notion of fairness proposed by Jung et al. [2020]: given a set of points $P$ of size $n$, a set of $k$ centers induces a fair clustering if every point in $P$ has a center among its $n/k$ closest neighbors. Mahabadi and Vakilian [2020] presented a $(p^{O(p)},7)$-bicriteria approximation for fair clustering with $\ell_p$-norm cost: every point finds a center within distance at most $7$ times its distance to its $(n/k)$-th closest neighbor and the $\ell_p$-norm…
Hong Kong University of Science and Technology（香港科技大学）
In this paper, we study the problem of fair clustering on the $k-$center objective. In fair clustering, the input is $N$ points, each belonging to at least one of $l$ protected groups, e.g. male, female, Asian, Hispanic. The objective is to cluster the $N$ points into $k$ clusters to minimize a classical clustering objective function. However, there is an additional constraint that each cluster needs to be fair, under some notion of fairness. This ensures that no group is either "over-represented" or "under-represented" in any cluster. Our work builds on the work of Chierichetti et al. (NIPS 2…
UC Santa Cruz（加州大学圣克鲁兹分校）；Dartmouth College（达特茅斯学院）
We study the problem of finding low-cost Fair Clusterings in data where each data point may belong to many protected groups. Our work significantly generalizes the seminal work of Chierichetti et.al. (NIPS 2017) as follows. - We allow the user to specify the parameters that define fair representation. More precisely, these parameters define the maximum over- and minimum under-representation of any group in any cluster. - Our clustering algorithm works on any $\ell_p$-norm objective (e.g. $k$-means, $k$-median, and $k$-center). Indeed, our algorithm transforms any vanilla clustering solution in…
Ben-Gurion University（本-古里安大学）；Toyota Technological Institute at Chicago（芝加哥丰田技术研究所）
We introduce the $(p,q)$-Fair Clustering problem. In this problem, we are given a set of points $P$ and a collection of different weight functions $W$. We would like to find a clustering which minimizes the $\ell_q$-norm of the vector over $W$ of the $\ell_p$-norms of the weighted distances of points in $P$ from the centers. This generalizes various clustering problems, including Socially Fair $k$-Median and $k$-Means, and is closely connected to other problems such as Densest $k$-Subgraph and Min $k$-Union. We utilize convex programming techniques to approximate the $(p,q)$-Fair Clustering pr…
Toyota Technological Institute at Chicago（芝加哥丰田技术研究院）
We present an $(e^{O(p)} \frac{\log \ell}{\log\log\ell})$-approximation algorithm for socially fair clustering with the $\ell_p$-objective. In this problem, we are given a set of points in a metric space. Each point belongs to one (or several) of $\ell$ groups. The goal is to find a $k$-medians, $k$-means, or, more generally, $\ell_p$-clustering that is simultaneously good for all of the groups. More precisely, we need to find a set of $k$ centers $C$ so as to minimize the maximum over all groups $j$ of $\sum_{u \text{ in group }j} d(u,C)^p$. The socially fair clustering problem was independen…
We study approximation algorithms for the socially fair $(\ell_p, k)$-clustering problem with $m$ groups, whose special cases include the socially fair $k$-median ($p=1$) and socially fair $k$-means ($p=2$) problems. We present (1) a polynomial-time $(5+2\sqrt{6})^p$-approximation with at most $k+m$ centers (2) a $(5+2\sqrt{6}+ε)^p$-approximation with $k$ centers in time $n^{2^{O(p)}\cdot m^2}$, and (3) a $(15+6\sqrt{6})^p$ approximation with $k$ centers in time $k^{m}\cdot\text{poly}(n)$. The first result is obtained via a refinement of the iterative rounding method using a sequence of linear…
Humboldt University of Berlin（柏林洪堡大学）；Hasso Plattner Institute, University of Potsdam（波茨坦大学哈索·普拉特纳研究所）；University of Vienna（维也纳大学）
The study of algorithmic fairness received growing attention recently. This stems from the awareness that bias in the input data for machine learning systems may result in discriminatory outputs. For clustering tasks, one of the most central notions of fairness is the formalization by Chierichetti, Kumar, Lattanzi, and Vassilvitskii [NeurIPS 2017]. A clustering is said to be fair, if each cluster has the same distribution of manifestations of a sensitive attribute as the whole input set. This is motivated by various applications where the objects to be clustered have sensitive attributes that …
EPFL（洛桑联邦理工学院）；Weizmann Institute of Science（魏茨曼科学研究所）；Yale University（耶鲁大学）
In a recent work, [19] studied the following "fair" variants of classical clustering problems such as $k$-means and $k$-median: given a set of $n$ data points in $\mathbb{R}^d$ and a binary type associated to each data point, the goal is to cluster the points while ensuring that the proportion of each type in each cluster is roughly the same as its underlying proportion. Subsequent work has focused on either extending this setting to when each data point has multiple, non-disjoint sensitive types such as race and gender [6], or to address the problem that the clustering algorithms in the above…
Clustering is a fundamental tool in data mining. It partitions points into groups (clusters) and may be used to make decisions for each point based on its group. However, this process may harm protected (minority) classes if the clustering algorithm does not adequately represent them in desirable clusters -- especially if the data is already biased. At NIPS 2017, Chierichetti et al. proposed a model for fair clustering requiring the representation in each cluster to (approximately) preserve the global fraction of each protected class. Restricting to two protected classes, they developed both a…
Approximation Algorithms for Fair Range Clustering
African Institute for Mathematical Sciences–Rwanda（卢旺达非洲数学科学研究所）；Microsoft Research–Redmond（微软研究院（雷德蒙德））；Toyota Technological Institute at Chicago（芝加哥丰田技术研究所）
A Polynomial-Time Approximation for Pairwise Fair $k$-Median Clustering
Portland State University（波特兰州立大学）；Ben Gurion University（本古里安大学）；University of Alberta（阿尔伯塔大学）；Toyota Technological Institute at Chicago (TTIC)（芝加哥丰田理工学院）
TTIC（丰田工业大学芝加哥分校）；CSAIL, MIT（麻省理工学院计算机科学与人工智能实验室）；MIT-IBM Watson AI Lab, IBM Research（IBM研究院麻省理工学院-IBM沃森人工智能实验室）；New Jersey Institute of Technology（新泽西理工学院）
We study the fair variant of the classic $k$-median problem introduced by Chierichetti et al. [2017]. In the standard $k$-median problem, given an input pointset $P$, the goal is to find $k$ centers $C$ and assign each input point to one of the centers in $C$ such that the average distance of points to their cluster center is minimized. In the fair variant of $k$-median, the points are colored, and the goal is to minimize the same average distance objective while ensuring that all clusters have an "approximately equal" number of points of each color. Chierichetti et al. proposed a two-phase al…
University of Chicago（芝加哥大学）；Toyota Technological Institute at Chicago (TTIC)（芝加哥丰田理工学院）
We study the problem of fair $k$-median where each cluster is required to have a fair representation of individuals from different groups. In the fair representation $k$-median problem, we are given a set of points $X$ in a metric space. Each point $x\in X$ belongs to one of $\ell$ groups. Further, we are given fair representation parameters $α_j$ and $β_j$ for each group $j\in [\ell]$. We say that a $k$-clustering $C_1, \cdots, C_k$ fairly represents all groups if the number of points from group $j$ in cluster $C_i$ is between $α_j |C_i|$ and $β_j |C_i|$ for every $j\in[\ell]$ and $i\in [k]$.…
A fair clustering instance is given a data set $A$ in which every point is assigned some color. Colors correspond to various protected attributes such as sex, ethnicity, or age. A fair clustering is an instance where membership of points in a cluster is uncorrelated with the coloring of the points. Of particular interest is the case where all colors are equally represented. If we have exactly two colors, Chierrichetti, Kumar, Lattanzi and Vassilvitskii (NIPS 2017) showed that various $k$-clustering objectives admit a constant factor approximation. Since then, a number of follow up work has att…
Harvard University（哈佛大学）；University of Maryland, College Park（马里兰大学帕克分校）
Clustering is a fundamental problem in unsupervised machine learning, and fair variants of it have recently received significant attention due to its societal implications. In this work we introduce a novel definition of individual fairness for clustering problems. Specifically, in our model, each point $j$ has a set of other points $\mathcal{S}_j$ that it perceives as similar to itself, and it feels that it is fairly treated if the quality of service it receives in the solution is $α$-close (in a multiplicative sense, for a given $α\geq 1$) to that of the points in $\mathcal{S}_j$. We begin o…
We study data clustering problems with $\ell_p$-norm objectives (e.g. $k$-Median and $k$-Means) in the context of individual fairness. The dataset consists of $n$ points, and we want to find $k$ centers such that (a) the objective is minimized, while (b) respecting the individual fairness constraint that every point $v$ has a center within a distance at most $r(v)$, where $r(v)$ is $v$'s distance to its $(n/k)$th nearest point. Jung, Kannan, and Lutz [FORC 2020] introduced this concept and designed a clustering algorithm with provable (approximate) fairness and objective guarantees for the $\e…
We study a variant of classical clustering formulations in the context of algorithmic fairness, known as diversity-aware clustering. In this variant we are given a collection of facility subsets, and a solution must contain at least a specified number of facilities from each subset while simultaneously minimizing the clustering objective ($k$-median or $k$-means). We investigate the fixed-parameter tractability of these problems and show several negative hardness and inapproximability results, even when we afford exponential running time with respect to some parameters. Motivated by these resu…
An instance of colorful k-center consists of points in a metric space that are colored red or blue, along with an integer k and a coverage requirement for each color. The goal is to find the smallest radius \r{ho} such that there exist balls of radius \r{ho} around k of the points that meet the coverage requirements. The motivation behind this problem is twofold. First, from fairness considerations: each color/group should receive a similar service guarantee, and second, from the algorithmic challenges it poses: this problem combines the difficulties of clustering along with the subset-sum pro…
Diversity-aware clustering: Computational Complexity and Approximation Algorithms
Max Planck Institute for Software Systems（马克斯·普朗克软件研究所）；CISPA Helmholtz Center for Information Security（亥姆霍兹信息安全中心）；KTH Royal Institute of Technology（皇家理工学院）
In this work, we study the socially fair $k$-median/$k$-means problem. We are given a set of points $P$ in a metric space $\mathcal{X}$ with a distance function $d(.,.)$. There are $\ell$ groups: $P_1,\dotsc,P_{\ell} \subseteq P$. We are also given a set $F$ of feasible centers in $\mathcal{X}$. The goal in the socially fair $k$-median problem is to find a set $C \subseteq F$ of $k$ centers that minimizes the maximum average cost over all the groups. That is, find $C$ that minimizes the objective function $Φ(C,P) \equiv \max_{j} \Big\{ \sum_{x \in P_j} d(C,x)/|P_j| \Big\}$, where $d(C,x)$ is t…
Constant-Factor Approximations for Doubly Constrained Fair k-Center, k-Median and k-Means
Department of Informatics, University of Cologne, Germany（科隆大学信息学院，德国）；Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Germany（杜伊斯堡-艾森大学数学与自然科学学院，德国）；Department of Informatics, University of Bonn, Germany（波恩大学信息学院，德国）
