最后一句话是谁说的?了解如何对在线讨论进行采样
Who has the last word? Understanding How to Sample Online Discussions
摘要:
在网上辩论中,个别论点相互支持或攻击,导致某些论点被认为比其他论点更相关。然而,在大型讨论中,读者往往被迫对所提出的论点的一个子集进行抽样。由于这种抽样很少是以原则性的方式进行的,用户可能无法阅读所有相关的论点,以了解辩论的全貌。本文有兴趣回答的问题,用户应该如何抽样在线对话,选择性地有利于目前合理或接受的立场在辩论中。我们应用论证理论和复杂网络的技术来构建一个模型,该模型可以预测规范合理的论点在在线讨论中的位置的概率。我们的模型表明,支持性回复的比例,评论收到的回复数量以及未回复评论的位置都决定了评论是合理论点的概率。我们表明,当答复的数量的程度分布是均匀的讨论,激烈的讨论,合理的参数的分布取决于奇偶性的图形水平。在支持性的讨论中,当人们远离词根时,得到合理评论的概率会增加。对于具有非齐次入度分布的讨论树,对于支持性讨论,我们观察到与以前相同的行为,而对于尖刻的讨论,我们不能观察到相同的基于奇偶性的分布。这一点可以从在线辩论平台Kialo获得的数据中得到验证。通过预测合理论点在回复树中的位置,我们可以建议读者应该抽样哪些论点,以掌握这些讨论中当前接受的观点。我们的模型对未来在线辩论平台的设计具有重要意义。
英文摘要:
In online debates individual arguments support or attack each other, leading to some subset of arguments being considered more relevant than others. However, in large discussions readers are often forced to sample a subset of the arguments being put forth. Since such sampling is rarely done in a principled manner, users may not read all the relevant arguments to get a full picture of the debate. This paper is interested in answering the question of how users should sample online conversations to selectively favour the currently justified or accepted positions in the debate. We apply techniques from argumentation theory and complex networks to build a model that predicts the probabilities of the normatively justified arguments given their location in online discussions. Our model shows that the proportion of replies that are supportive, the number of replies that comments receive, and the locations of un-replied comments all determine the probability that a comment is a justified argument. We show that when the degree distribution of the number of replies is homogeneous along the discussion, for acrimonious discussions, the distribution of justified arguments depends on the parity of the graph level. In supportive discussions the probability of having justified comments increases as one moves away from the root. For discussion trees that have a non-homogeneous in-degree distribution, for supportive discussions we observe the same behaviour as before, while for acrimonious discussions we cannot observe the same parity-based distribution. This is verified with data obtained from the online debating platform Kialo. By predicting the locations of the justified arguments in reply trees, we can suggest which arguments readers should sample to grasp the currently accepted opinions in such discussions. Our models have important implications for the design of future online debating platforms.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。