引文是否应该从每个起源部分单独计数
Should Citations be Counted Separately from Each Originating Section
摘要:
文章被引用用于不同的目的,因此在计算引用时区分原因可以提供更细粒度的引用计数信息。虽然识别和汇总每个引用的单独原因可能不切实际,但记录来自不同文章部分的引用数量可能会阐明引用计数背后的一般原因(例如,110篇引文= 10篇引言引文+ 100篇方法引文)。为了帮助调查这是否可能是一个实用和通用的解决方案,本文比较了来自6个不同标准部分的1900万篇引文,这些引文来自PubMed Central开放获取文章中的22个字段中的21个。在引用最多的章节中,不同领域之间存在明显的非系统性差异,一个章节的引用与另一个章节的引用重叠的程度,在大多数情况下都有一定程度的重叠。因此,在科学范围内,章节标题是部分不可靠的引文背景指标,即使它们在个别领域内更标准。它们仍然可以在领域内使用,以帮助识别具有某种影响力的个别高引用文章,特别是方法论(方法)或背景设置(介绍),但需要专家判断来验证结果。
英文摘要:
Articles are cited for different purposes and differentiating between reasons when counting citations may therefore give finer-grained citation count information. Although identifying and aggregating the individual reasons for each citation may be impractical, recording the number of citations that originate from different article sections might illuminate the general reasons behind a citation count (e.g., 110 citations = 10 Introduction citations + 100 Methods citations). To help investigate whether this could be a practical and universal solution, this article compares 19 million citations with DOIs from six different standard sections in 799,055 PubMed Central open access articles across 21 out of 22 fields. There are apparently non-systematic differences between fields in the most citing sections and the extent to which citations from one section overlap with citations from another, with some degree of overlap in most cases. Thus, at a science-wide level, section headings are partly unreliable indicators of citation context, even if they are more standard within individual fields. They may still be used within fields to help identify individual highly cited articles that have had one type of impact, especially methodological (Methods) or context setting (Introduction), but expert judgement is needed to validate the results.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。