Recently, a number of formal systems for Nonstandard Analysis restricted to the language of finite types, i.e. nonstandard arithmetic, have been proposed. We single out one particular system by Dinis-Gaspar, which is categorised by the authors as being part of intuitionistic nonstandard arithmetic. Their system is indeed inconsistent with the Transfer axiom of Nonstandard Analysis, and the latter axiom is classical in nature as it implies (higher-order) comprehension. In this paper, we answer the following questions:
(Q1) In the spirit of Reverse Mathematics, what is the minimal fragment of Transfer that is inconsistent with the Dinis-Gaspar system?
(Q2) What other axioms are inconsistent with the Dinis-Gaspar system?
Perhaps surprisingly, the answer to the second question shows that the Dinis-Gaspar system is inconsistent with a number of (non-classical) continuity theorems which one would -- in our opinion -- categorise as intuitionistic. Finally, we show that the Dinis-Gaspar system involves a standard part map, suggesting this system also pushes the boundary of what still counts as 'Nonstandard Analysis' or 'internal set theory'.
Some nonstandard equivalences in Reverse Mathematics
逆向数学(英语:Reverse Mathematics,简称RM)是数学数学基础中的一个程序,由弗里德曼创立,辛普森广泛发展。RM的目的是找到证明普通(即非集合理论)数学定理所需的最小公理。在大多数情况下,人们也得到了定理和它的最小公理之间的等价性。这种等价性建立在一个称为基本理论的弱逻辑系统中;辛普森称之为数学自然的四个突出公理拥有大量的这种等价性。本文证明了非标准分析中的一些公理等价于不涉及非标准分析的普通数学定理。这些等价性在最近由van den Berg和作者提出的弱基理论中得到了证明。特别地,我们的基础理论具有初等函数算术的一阶强度,与本文的原始版本[22]形成对比。我们的结果结合辛普森的标准的自然性建议的争议点,非标准分析实际上是数学上的自然。