arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1702.02827stat.ME
收藏

结合对照可以提高两阶段关联研究的功效

Combining controls can improve power in two-stage association studies

James Liley

摘要:

高维病例对照研究在生物科学中无处不在,特别是基因组学。为了在限制成本的同时最大限度地提高功效,并最大限度地降低第一类错误率,研究人员通常会在进行进一步分析之前,在第二次独立队列实验中重复研究结果。本文介绍了一种方法,其中控制(或情况下)从发现队列的样本重复使用的复制研究。这种方法的理论意义进行了讨论和模拟用于比较性能对标准方法在一系列的情况下。在几种常见的研究设计中,共享控制方法允许在保留1型错误率控制的同时大幅提高功效。当对照样本难以招募或确定时,出现了一个重要的潜在应用领域;例如在疾病间比较或退行性疾病研究中。使用类似的方法,提出了一个程序的“部分复制”使用一个新的独立的队列组成的控制。当无法进行完整的复制程序时,可使用此方法对结果进行某些验证。与标准程序相比,新方法对研究队列中的混杂因素具有不同的敏感性,在应用中必须考虑到这一点。在这些情况下的1型错误率的分析和经验得出,并提供了一个在线工具,用于比较功率和错误率。尽管必须仔细考虑所有必要的假设,但这种方法可以在全基因组关联研究(GWAS)和其他应用中更有效地使用数据。

英文摘要:

High dimensional case control studies are ubiquitous in the biological sciences, particularly genomics. To maximise power while constraining cost and to minimise type-1 error rates, researchers typically seek to replicate findings in a second experiment on independent cohorts before proceeding with further analyses. This paper presents a method in which control (or case) samples from the discovery cohort are re-used in the replication study. The theoretical implications of this method are discussed and simulations used to compare performance against the standard method in a range of circumstances. In several common study designs, a shared-control method allows a substantial improvement in power while retaining type-1 error rate control. An important area of potential application arises when control samples are difficult to recruit or ascertain; for example in inter-disease comparisons, or studies on degenerative diseases. Using similar methods, a procedure is proposed for `partial replication' using a new independent cohort consisting of only controls. This methods can be used to provide some validation of findings when a full replication procedure is not possible. The new method has differing sensitivity to confounding in study cohorts compared to the standard procedure, which must be considered in its application. Type-1 error rates in these scenarios are analytically and empirically derived, and an online tool for comparing power and error rates is provided. Although careful consideration must be made of all necessary assumptions, this method can enable more efficient use of data in genome-wide association studies (GWAS) and other applications.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑