High dimensional case control studies are ubiquitous in the biological sciences, particularly genomics. To maximise power while constraining cost and to minimise type-1 error rates, researchers typically seek to replicate findings in a second experiment on independent cohorts before proceeding with further analyses.
This paper presents a method in which control (or case) samples from the discovery cohort are re-used in the replication study. The theoretical implications of this method are discussed and simulations used to compare performance against the standard method in a range of circumstances. In several common study designs, a shared-control method allows a substantial improvement in power while retaining type-1 error rate control.
An important area of potential application arises when control samples are difficult to recruit or ascertain; for example in inter-disease comparisons, or studies on degenerative diseases. Using similar methods, a procedure is proposed for `partial replication' using a new independent cohort consisting of only controls. This methods can be used to provide some validation of findings when a full replication procedure is not possible.
The new method has differing sensitivity to confounding in study cohorts compared to the standard procedure, which must be considered in its application. Type-1 error rates in these scenarios are analytically and empirically derived, and an online tool for comparing power and error rates is provided.
Although careful consideration must be made of all necessary assumptions, this method can enable more efficient use of data in genome-wide association studies (GWAS) and other applications.
When Method Choice Changes Statistical Inference: A Comparison of a Baseline Two-Stage Approach and Bayesian Joint Modeling for Longitudinal and Survival Data in an HIV Clinical Trial
Meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy with multiple disease stages: combining stage-specific and merged-stage data
Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol(布里斯托大学布里斯托医学院人口健康科学);Manchester Centre for Health Economics, University of Manchester(曼彻斯特大学曼彻斯特卫生经济学中心)
Genomic Data Analysis using a Two Stage Expectation Propagation Algorithm for Analysis of Sparse Bayesian High-Dimensional Instrumental Variables Regression