arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1612.04174cs.CLstat.APstat.ML
收藏

句子理解中的提取模型:贝叶斯分层模型的计算评价

Models of retrieval in sentence comprehension: A computational evaluation using Bayesian hierarchical modeling

University of Potsdam(波茨坦大学)

Bruno Nicenboim, Shravan Vasishth

摘要:

对干扰的研究表明,非相邻词之间依存关系的形成依赖于基于线索的提取机制。两种不同的模型可以解释干扰的主要预测之一,即,当几个项目共享与检索线索相关的特征时,检索站点的减速:Lewis和Vasishth(2005)基于激活的模型和McElree(2000)的直接存取模型。尽管这两个模型几乎可以互换使用,但它们基于不同的假设,并预测阅读时间和反应准确性之间的关系。基于激活的模型遵循ACT-R的假设,其检索过程表现为单方差证据之间的对数正态竞争。在该模型下,检索的准确率由比赛的获胜者决定,检索时间由其积累率决定。相比之下,直接存取模型假设了一种记忆模型,其中只有检索的概率在项目之间变化;在这种模型中,延迟的差异是可能性和修复不正确检索的副产品。我们在贝叶斯分层框架中实现了这两种模型,以便对其进行评估和比较。我们表明,某些方面的数据更适合在直接存取模型下比基于激活的模型。我们认为,这一发现并不排除检索可能表现为一个种族模型的可能性,与ACT-R框架中的假设不太接近。我们表明,通过引入激活模型的修改,即通过假设用于检索不正确项目的证据的积累不仅更慢,而且更嘈杂(即,正确和不正确项的不同方差),该模型可以提供与直接存取模型一样好的拟合。

英文摘要:

Research on interference has provided evidence that the formation of dependencies between non-adjacent words relies on a cue-based retrieval mechanism. Two different models can account for one of the main predictions of interference, i.e., a slowdown at a retrieval site, when several items share a feature associated with a retrieval cue: Lewis and Vasishth's (2005) activation-based model and McElree's (2000) direct access model. Even though these two models have been used almost interchangeably, they are based on different assumptions and predict differences in the relationship between reading times and response accuracy. The activation-based model follows the assumptions of ACT-R, and its retrieval process behaves as a lognormal race between accumulators of evidence with a single variance. Under this model, accuracy of the retrieval is determined by the winner of the race and retrieval time by its rate of accumulation. In contrast, the direct access model assumes a model of memory where only the probability of retrieval varies between items; in this model, differences in latencies are a by-product of the possibility and repairing incorrect retrievals. We implemented both models in a Bayesian hierarchical framework in order to evaluate them and compare them. We show that some aspects of the data are better fit under the direct access model than under the activation-based model. We suggest that this finding does not rule out the possibility that retrieval may be behaving as a race model with assumptions that follow less closely the ones from the ACT-R framework. We show that by introducing a modification of the activation model, i.e, by assuming that the accumulation of evidence for retrieval of incorrect items is not only slower but noisier (i.e., different variances for the correct and incorrect items), the model can provide a fit as good as the one of the direct access model.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑