The ability to categorize problems based upon underlying principles, rather than surface features or contexts, is considered one of several proxy predictors of expertise in problem solving. With inspiration from the classic study by Chi, Feltovich, and Glaser, we assess the distribution of expertise among introductory physics students by asking three introductory physics classes, each with more than a hundred students, to categorize mechanics problems based upon similarity of solution. We compare their categorization with those of physics graduate students and faculty members. To evaluate the effect of problem context on students' ability to categorize, two sets of problems were developed for categorization. Some problems in one set included those available from the prior study by Chi et al. We find a large overlap between calculus-based introductory students and graduate students with regard to their categorizations that were assessed as "good." Our findings, which contrast with those of Chi et al., suggest that there is a wide distribution of expertise in mechanics among introductory and graduate students. Although the categorization task is conceptual, introductory students in the calculus-based course performed better than those in the algebra-based course. Qualitative trends in categorization of problems are similar between the non-Chi problems and problems available from the Chi study used in our study although the Chi problems used are more difficult on average.
Assessing Student Expertise in Introductory Physics with Isomorphic Problems, Part I: Performance on Non-intuitive Problem Pair from Introductory Physics
Assessing Student Expertise in Introductory Physics with Isomorphic Problems, Part II: Effect of Some Potential Factors on Problem Solving and Transfer
An empirical approach to interpreting card-sorting data
自30年前首次发表以来,Chi et al.的开创性的论文专家和新手分类的介绍性问题,导致了过多的后续研究领域内外的物理[池等认知科学5,121 - 152(1981)]。这些研究通常包括“卡片分类”练习,参与者将问题分组。虽然这种技术确实可以洞察解决问题的方法,但简单的描述性统计往往无法找到专家和新手之间的显着差异。在超越描述性统计,我们描述了一种新的微观方法,考虑到卡的个人身份,并使用图论和模型来可视化,分析和解释问题分类实验。我们将这些方法应用到一个介绍性的物理(力学)问题分类实验中,发现分类结果的大部分变化不是由于分类器是专家还是新手,而是由于一个独立的特征,我们称之为“堆叠器”与“散布器”。“专家-新手的区别只占较小的变化量,这一事实可以解释在进行这些实验时频繁出现的零结果。
Progression in self-efficacy, interest, identity, sense of belonging, perceived recognition and effectiveness of peer interaction of physics majors and comparison with non-majors and Ph.D. students
Data Science Education in Undergraduate Physics: Lessons Learned from a Community of Practice
Center for Advanced Systems Understanding, Helmholtz-Zentrum Dresden-Rossendorf(德累斯顿-罗森多夫亥姆霍兹中心高级系统理解中心);University of Mount Union(芒特尤尼恩大学);American Association of Physics Teachers(美国物理教师协会);University of Maryland(马里兰大学);National Institute of Standards and Technology(美国国家标准与技术研究院);Questrom School of Business at Boston University(波士顿大学奎斯特罗姆商学院)