足球经济学:美式足球剖析;来自7年NFL比赛数据的证据
Footballonomics: The Anatomy of American Football; Evidence from 7 years of NFL game data
摘要:
NFL球队会做出理性的决定吗?哪些因素可能影响NFL比赛获胜的概率?一支球队如何从一次令人沮丧的拦截中恢复过来?在这项研究中,我们首先研究的假设,合理的教练,也就是说,教练的决定总是理性的最大化的预期得分。我们通过分析在过去7个NFL赛季中为两个特定的比赛所做的决定来拒绝这一假设;(i)触地得分(PAT)和(ii)第四次进攻决定。在拒绝了理性教练假设之后,我们继续研究收集的详细比赛数据如何潜在地为比赛日的决策提供信息。虽然NFL球队的工作人员肯定有一个直觉,哪些因素是赢得比赛的关键,在这项工作中,我们采取了数据驱动的方法,并提供了量化的证据,使用2009年至2015年7年期间的NFL比赛的大型数据集。特别是,我们使用了逻辑斯谛回归模型来识别的影响和相应的统计显著性的因素,如控球时间,罚球码数,传球和抢攻之间的平衡等,我们的结果清楚地表明,避免失误是赢得比赛的最佳策略,但失误可以克服让进攻在球场上更多的时间。最后,我们结合我们的描述性模型与统计引导,以提供一个预测引擎,为即将到来的NFL比赛。我们的评估表明,即使只考虑少量(直接)因素,我们也可以实现非常好的预测精度。特别是,2014年和2015年的平均准确率约为63%。这种性能与更复杂的最先进的预测系统相当,同时在60%的时间内优于专家分析师。
英文摘要:
Do NFL teams make rational decisions? What factors potentially affect the probability of wining a game in NFL? How can a team come back from a demoralizing interception? In this study we begin by examining the hypothesis of rational coaching, that is, coaching decisions are always rational with respect to the maximization of the expected points scored. We reject this hypothesis by analyzing the decisions made in the past 7 NFL seasons for two particular plays; (i) the Point(s) After Touchdown (PAT) and (ii) the fourth down decisions. Having rejected the rational coaching hypothesis we move on to examine how the detailed game data collected can potentially inform game-day decisions. While NFL teams personnel definitely have an intuition on which factors are crucial for winning a game, in this work we take a data-driven approach and provide quantifiable evidence using a large dataset of NFL games for the 7-year period between 2009 and 2015. In particular, we use a logistic regression model to identify the impact and the corresponding statistical significance of factors such as possession time, number of penalty yards, balance between passing and rushing offense etc. Our results clearly imply that avoiding turnovers is the best strategy for winning a game but turnovers can be overcome with letting the offense on the field for more time. Finally we combine our descriptive model with statistical bootstrap in order to provide a prediction engine for upcoming NFL games. Our evaluations indicate that even by only considering a small number of (straightforward) factors, we can achieve a very good prediction accuracy. In particular, the average accuracy during seasons 2014 and 2015 is approximately 63%. This performance is comparable to the more complicated state-of-the-art prediction systems, while it outperforms expert analysts 60% of the time.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。