arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1607.01756stat.AP
收藏

高中橄榄球运动对认知功能和心理健康影响的观察性研究方案

Protocol for an Observational Study on the Effects of Playing High School Football on Later Life Cognitive Functioning and Mental Health

Sameer K. Deshpande, Raiden B. Hasegawa, Amanda R. Rabinowitz, John Whyte, Carol L. Roan, Andrew Tabatabaei, Michael Baiocchi, Jason H. Karlawish, Christina L. … 展开作者

Sameer K. Deshpande, Raiden B. Hasegawa, Amanda R. Rabinowitz, John Whyte, Carol L. Roan, Andrew Tabatabaei, Michael Baiocchi, Jason H. Karlawish, Christina L. Master, Dylan S. Small

摘要:

NFL球员头部受伤与晚年神经功能衰退之间的潜在因果关系可能对青少年和高中足球项目的参与者产生广泛的影响。然而,专业水平的脑创伤风险可能与青年和高中水平的脑创伤风险不同,参与这些水平的长期影响尚不清楚。为了调查高中橄榄球运动对晚年抑郁和认知功能的影响,我们提出了一项回顾性观察研究,使用1957年威斯康星州高中毕业生的威斯康星州纵向研究(WLS)的数据。我们比较了1,153名参加校队足球比赛的高中男生和2,751名没有参加校队足球比赛的男生。1,951名对照组受试者没有进行任何运动,其余800名对照组受试者进行非接触性运动。我们专注于在65岁时测量的两个主要结果:测量语言流畅性和记忆力的复合认知结果和改良的CES-D抑郁评分。为了控制潜在的混杂因素,我们调整了暴露前的协变量,如匹配的IQ和基于模型的协变量调整。我们将进行一个有序的测试程序,使用所有2,751个控制,同时控制可能无法测量的差异之间的学生谁参加体育运动和那些谁没有。我们将定量评估结果对潜在未测量混杂因素的敏感性。该研究还将考虑临床感兴趣的几个次要结果,如攻击和酗酒。丰富的预暴露变量集,相对无偏的采样,以及WLS数据集的纵向性质,使得所提出的分析在主要依赖于具有神经系统症状的足球运动员的便利样本的相关研究中是独一无二的。

英文摘要:

A potential causal relationship between head injuries sustained by NFL players and later-life neurological decline may have broad implications for participants in youth and high school football programs. However, brain trauma risk at the professional level may be different than that at the youth and high school levels and the long-term effects of participation at these levels is as-yet unclear. To investigate the effect of playing high school football on later life depression and cognitive functioning, we propose a retrospective observational study using data from the Wisconsin Longitudinal Study (WLS) of graduates from Wisconsin high schools in 1957. We compare 1,153 high school males who played varsity football to 2,751 male students who did not. 1,951 of the control subjects did not play any sport and the remaining 800 controls played a non-contact sport. We focus on two primary outcomes measured at age 65: a composite cognitive outcome measuring verbal fluency and memory and the modified CES-D depression score. To control for potential confounders we adjust for pre-exposure covariates such as IQ with matching and model-based covariate adjustment. We will conduct an ordered testing procedure that uses all 2,751 controls while controlling for possible unmeasured differences between students who played sports and those who did not. We will quantitatively assess the sensitivity of the results to potential unmeasured confounding. The study will also consider several secondary outcomes of clinical interest such as aggression and heavy drinking. The rich set of pre-exposure variables, relatively unbiased sampling, and longitudinal nature of the WLS dataset make the proposed analysis unique among related studies that rely primarily on convenience samples of football players with reported neurological symptoms.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑