arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1404.7045cs.DL
收藏

基于引用的搜索引擎的经验证据:微软学术搜索死了吗?

Empirical Evidences in Citation-Based Search Engines: Is Microsoft Academic Search dead?

Enrique Orduna-Malea, Juan Manuel Ayllon, Alberto Martin-Martin, Emilio Delgado Lopez-Cozar

摘要:

本工作文件的目的是总结科学界提供的关于两个主要的基于引用的学术搜索引擎:谷歌学术和微软学术搜索之间的比较的主要经验证据,特别注意以下问题:覆盖范围,期刊排名之间的相关性,以及这些学术搜索引擎的使用。此外,自我阐述的数据提供,旨在提供有关这些工具在网络上的流行程度的当前证据,通过测量这些工具中提到的丰富文件PDF,PPT和DOC的数量,这两个产品接收的外部链接的数量,以及来自Google趋势的搜索查询频率。MAS获得的糟糕结果让我们意外地发现:Microsoft Academic Search自2013年以来已经过时。因此,工作文件第二部分旨在提出一些数据,说明这种缺乏更新的情况。为此,我们收集了自2000年以来Microsoft Academic Search索引的总记录数。数据显示,被编入索引的文件数量从2010年的2,346,228份突然下降到2013年的8,147份和2014年的802份。这一减少也是根据15个专题领域提供的。考虑到这些问题,似乎不仅微软学术搜索不适合学术界和学生搜索文章(他们大多使用谷歌或谷歌学术),而且几乎被文献计量学家忽视,

英文摘要:

The goal of this working paper is to summarize the main empirical evidences provided by the scientific community as regards the comparison between the two main citation based academic search engines: Google Scholar and Microsoft Academic Search, paying special attention to the following issues: coverage, correlations between journal rankings, and usage of these academic search engines. Additionally, selfelaborated data is offered, which are intended to provide current evidence about the popularity of these tools on the Web, by measuring the number of rich files PDF, PPT and DOC in which these tools are mentioned, the amount of external links that both products receive, and the search queries frequency from Google Trends. The poor results obtained by MAS led us to an unexpected and unnoticed discovery: Microsoft Academic Search is outdated since 2013. Therefore, the second part of the working paper aims at advancing some data demonstrating this lack of update. For this purpose we gathered the number of total records indexed by Microsoft Academic Search since 2000. The data shows an abrupt drop in the number of documents indexed from 2,346,228 in 2010 to 8,147 in 2013 and 802 in 2014. This decrease is offered according to 15 thematic areas as well. In view of these problems it seems logical not only that Microsoft Academic Searchwas poorly used to search for articles by academics and students, who mostly use Google or Google Scholar, but virtually ignored by bibliometricians

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑