arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1312.6439q-bio.GN
收藏

序列捕获与限制性位点相关DNA测序在系统地理学中的应用

Sequence Capture Versus Restriction Site Associated DNA Sequencing for Phylogeography

Michael G. Harvey, Brian Tilston Smith, Travis C. Glenn, Brant C. Faircloth, Robb T. Brumfield

摘要:

用大规模并行测序方法生成的基因组数据集有可能推动系统学向新的和令人兴奋的方向发展,但选择合适的标记和方法并不简单。我们对来自非模型新热带鸟类的同一组样本应用了两种特别有希望进行系统学的方法,即限制性位点相关DNA测序(RAD-Seq)和超保守元件(UCE)的序列捕获(Seq-cap)。我们发现,RAD-Seq和Seq-cap都产生了包含数千个基因座和SNP的基因组数据集,并且推断的群体分配和物种树在数据集之间是一致的。然而,基于模型的人口统计学参数的估计值在数据集之间存在差异,特别是当我们使用基于等位基因频率谱的方法估计参数时。我们观察到的差异可能是由于不同方法之间序列数据的组装、比对和过滤的差异造成的,我们的研究结果表明,在使用等位基因频率估计低覆盖率测序数据的参数时,需要谨慎。我们进一步探索了使用模拟Seq-cap和RAD-Seq类数据集的方法之间的差异。模拟数据的分析表明,从500到5000增加基因座的数量增加系统发育一致性因素和人口统计参数估计的准确性和精确性,但增加基因座的数量超过5000导致收益最小。从64 bp到500 bp的基因座长度增加改善系统发育一致性因素和最小的收益,观察基因座长度超过500 bp,但基因座长度并不影响人口统计学参数估计的准确性和精密度。我们讨论了我们的结果相对于可用的数据收集方法的多样性,我们提供了利用下一代测序系统学研究的建议。

英文摘要:

Genomic datasets generated with massively parallel sequencing methods have the potential to propel systematics in new and exciting directions, but selecting appropriate markers and methods is not straightforward. We applied two approaches with particular promise for systematics, restriction site associated DNA sequencing (RAD-Seq) and sequence capture (Seq-cap) of ultraconserved elements (UCEs), to the same set of samples from a non-model, Neotropical bird. We found that both RAD-Seq and Seq-cap produced genomic datasets containing thousands of loci and SNPs and that the inferred population assignments and species trees were concordant between datasets. However, model-based estimates of demographic parameters differed between datasets, particularly when we estimated the parameters using a method based on allele frequency spectra. The differences we observed may result from differences in assembly, alignment, and filtering of sequence data between methods, and our findings suggest that caution is warranted when using allele frequencies to estimate parameters from low-coverage sequencing data. We further explored the differences between methods using simulated Seq-cap- and RAD-Seq-like datasets. Analyses of simulated data suggest that increasing the number of loci from 500 to 5000 increased phylogenetic concordance factors and the accuracy and precision of demographic parameter estimates, but increasing the number of loci past 5000 resulted in minimal gains. Increasing locus length from 64 bp to 500 bp improved phylogenetic concordance factors and minimal gains were observed with loci longer than 500 bp, but locus length did not influence the accuracy and precision of demographic parameter estimates. We discuss our results relative to the diversity of data collection methods available, and we provide advice for harnessing next-generation sequencing for systematics research.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑