arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1301.5782cs.DL
收藏

临床实践指南的质量与参考文献引用的相关性

Association between quality of clinical practice guidelines and citations given to their references

Jens Peter Andersen

摘要:

有人建议,不同类型的文件的文献计量学分析可能会揭示新的方面的研究业绩。在医学研究中,许多研究类型在研究过程中发挥着不同的作用,研究类型的证据水平与不同的引用率有关。这项研究的重点是临床实践指南,这些指南应该收集关于给定主题的最高证据,以便为从业者提供最佳建议。使用AGREE评分测量的临床实践指南的质量与这些指南中使用的参考文献的引用进行比较,因为假设更好的指南是基于更高引用的参考文献。AGREE评分是从对一些疾病和治疗的临床实践指南的评论中收集的。他们的参考文献来自Web of Science,引用计数使用面向项目的z得分和PPtop-10%指标进行标准化。两项引文指标与临床实践指南的AGREE评分呈正相关,并发现了一些潜在的混杂因素。虽然不能排除混杂因素,但结果表明确定的混杂因素的可能性较低。研究结果为引文分析提供了新的视角和应用。

英文摘要:

It has been suggested that bibliometric analysis of different document types may reveal new aspects of research performance. In medical research a number of study types play different roles in the research process and it has been shown, that the evidence-level of study types is associated with varying citation rates. This study focuses on clinical practice guidelines, which are supposed to gather the highest evidence on a given topic to give the best possible recommendation for practitioners. The quality of clinical practice guidelines, measured using the AGREE score, is compared to the citations given to the references used in these guidelines, as it is hypothesised, that better guidelines are based on higher cited references. AGREE scores are gathered from reviews of clinical practice guidelines on a number of diseases and treatments. Their references are collected from Web of Science and citation counts are normalised using the item-oriented z-score and the PPtop-10% indicators. A positive correlation between both citation indicators and the AGREE score of clinical practice guidelines is found. Some potential confounding factors are identified. While confounding cannot be excluded, results indicate low likelihood for the identified confounders. The results provide a new perspective to and application of citation analysis.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑