arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1301.1208stat.MEmath.STstat.TH
收藏

无真值的显著性检验

Significance testing without truth

William Perkins, Mark Tygert, Rachel Ward

摘要:

一种流行的显著性检验方法是决定给定的假设统计模型是否可能为真(或假)。统计决策论为这种方法提供了基础,它要求每一个显著性检验都要对所考虑的假设/模型的真实性做出决定。不幸的是,即使在考虑任何数据之前,许多有趣和有用的模型显然是错误的(也就是说,不完全正确)。幸运的是,在实践中,显著性检验只需要衡量观察到的数据与假设/模型的一致性(或不一致性),而不需要询问假设是否可能是真的(或假的),或者是否有其他选择可能是真的(或假的)。在这个实际的公式中,只有当在假设被检验的假设的同时计算概率时观察到的数据非常不可能时,显著性检验才拒绝假设/模型;显著性检验只衡量观察到的数据是否可能使假设无效,并且不能决定假设-无论多么无误地错误-在没有任何数据的情况下可能先验地错误。

英文摘要:

A popular approach to significance testing proposes to decide whether the given hypothesized statistical model is likely to be true (or false). Statistical decision theory provides a basis for this approach by requiring every significance test to make a decision about the truth of the hypothesis/model under consideration. Unfortunately, many interesting and useful models are obviously false (that is, not exactly true) even before considering any data. Fortunately, in practice a significance test need only gauge the consistency (or inconsistency) of the observed data with the assumed hypothesis/model -- without enquiring as to whether the assumption is likely to be true (or false), or whether some alternative is likely to be true (or false). In this practical formulation, a significance test rejects a hypothesis/model only if the observed data is highly improbable when calculating the probability while assuming the hypothesis being tested; the significance test only gauges whether the observed data likely invalidates the assumed hypothesis, and cannot decide that the assumption -- however unmistakably false -- is likely to be false a priori, without any data.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑