arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1209.4495stat.ME
收藏

核密度估计新的交叉验证带宽选择器的比较研究

A comparative study of new cross-validated bandwidth selectors for kernel density estimation

Enno Mammen, Maria Dolores Martinez Miranda, Jens Perch Nielsen, Stefan Sperlich

摘要:

最近的贡献内核平滑表明,交叉验证的带宽选择器的性能显着提高间接。间接交叉验证首先从一个比原始问题更粗糙和困难的平滑问题估计经典的交叉验证带宽,然后重新缩放该间接带宽以成为原始问题的带宽。这种方法的动机来自于观察,即当平滑问题很困难时,经典的交叉验证往往会更好地工作。在本文中,我们发现,间接交叉验证的性能提高理论和实践中的多项式阶的间接核的增加,高斯核作为限制核的多项式阶趋于无穷大。这些理论和实际结果支持了经常提出的选择高斯核作为间接核。然而,对于做验证,我们的研究表明渐近理论和实际性能之间的差异。至于间接交叉验证,在渐近理论中,间接do-validation的性能随着所使用的间接核的多项式阶数的增加而提高。但是这种理论上的改进并没有延续到实践中,并且原始的do验证似乎仍然是我们首选的带宽选择器。我们还考虑插件估计和插件带宽和交叉验证带宽的组合。这些后者的带宽也不优于原始的do-validation估计。

英文摘要:

Recent contributions to kernel smoothing show that the performance of cross-validated bandwidth selectors improve significantly from indirectness. Indirect crossvalidation first estimates the classical cross-validated bandwidth from a more rough and difficult smoothing problem than the original one and then rescales this indirect bandwidth to become a bandwidth of the original problem. The motivation for this approach comes from the observation that classical crossvalidation tends to work better when the smoothing problem is difficult. In this paper we find that the performance of indirect crossvalidation improves theoretically and practically when the polynomial order of the indirect kernel increases, with the Gaussian kernel as limiting kernel when the polynomial order goes to infinity. These theoretical and practical results support the often proposed choice of the Gaussian kernel as indirect kernel. However, for do-validation our study shows a discrepancy between asymptotic theory and practical performance. As for indirect crossvalidation, in asymptotic theory the performance of indirect do-validation improves with increasing polynomial order of the used indirect kernel. But this theoretical improvements do not carry over to practice and the original do-validation still seems to be our preferred bandwidth selector. We also consider plug-in estimation and combinations of plug-in bandwidths and crossvalidated bandwidths. These latter bandwidths do not outperform the original do-validation estimator either.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑