论可靠的同行评议程序
On a Reliable Peer-Review Process
摘要:
我们提出了一个增强的同行评审过程中,鼓励评审员如实披露他们的评论。我们首先使用贝叶斯模型对该过程进行建模,其中考虑了手稿质量的不确定性。之后,我们引入了一个评分函数来评估报告的评论。在温和的假设下,我们表明,评论家严格最大化他们的期望分数说实话。我们还展示了如何使用这些分数来达成共识。
英文摘要:
We propose an enhanced peer-review process where the reviewers are encouraged to truthfully disclose their reviews. We start by modelling that process using a Bayesian model where the uncertainty regarding the quality of the manuscript is taken into account. After that, we introduce a scoring function to evaluate the reported reviews. Under mild assumptions, we show that reviewers strictly maximize their expected scores by telling the truth. We also show how those scores can be used in order to reach consensus.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。