arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1201.4638cs.DL
收藏

期刊影响因子的替代品:I3和前10%(或前25%?)最高被引论文

Alternatives to the Journal Impact Factor: I3 and the Top-10% (or Top-25%?) of the Most-Highly Cited Papers

Loet Leydesdorff

摘要:

期刊影响因子(Journal Impact Factors,简称IF)可以被认为是历史上第一次使用两年平均值来规范引文分布的尝试。然而,人们已经认识到,引文分布在科学领域之间存在差异,需要对此进行规范化。此外,平均值或任何中心趋势曲线都不能很好地代表引文分布,因为这些分布是偏斜的。在过去几年中,为解决这两个问题采取了重要步骤。首先,可以使用引用受众作为参考集在文章级别进行规范化。其次,可以使用非参数统计来检验评级之间差异的显著性。基于引用分数计算的最高引用论文(前10%或前四分之一)的比例可以提供当前IF的替代方案。这一指标直观简单,便于进行统计检验,符合最新技术水平。

英文摘要:

Journal Impact Factors (IFs) can be considered historically as the first attempt to normalize citation distributions by using averages over two years. However, it has been recognized that citation distributions vary among fields of science and that one needs to normalize for this. Furthermore, the mean-or any central-tendency statistics-is not a good representation of the citation distribution because these distributions are skewed. Important steps have been taken to solve these two problems during the last few years. First, one can normalize at the article level using the citing audience as the reference set. Second, one can use non-parametric statistics for testing the significance of differences among ratings. A proportion of most-highly cited papers (the top-10% or top-quartile) on the basis of fractional counting of the citations may provide an alternative to the current IF. This indicator is intuitively simple, allows for statistical testing, and accords with the state of the art.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑