影响因子波动性对单一论文的综合分析
Impact Factor volatility to a single paper: A comprehensive analysis
摘要:
我们通过分析Clarivate Analytics 2017年期刊引文报告中11639种期刊上发表的3,088,511篇论文的数据,研究了一篇论文如何影响影响因子(IF)。我们发现如果是高度不稳定的。例如,381种期刊的首引论文导致其IF增加超过0.5分,而818种期刊的相对增加超过25%。十分之一的期刊通过前三篇被引用的论文,其IF提高了50%以上。由于单篇论文对IF的影响与期刊规模成反比,因此对于高被引论文,小期刊比大期刊获得的奖励更大,而对于低被引论文,它们受到的惩罚更大,特别是如果它们的IF很高。这种扭曲的奖励机制激励高IF期刊保持规模小,在排名中保持竞争力。我们讨论了出现在著名期刊上的突破性论文的影响。我们质疑IF排名的可靠性,因为IF对数千种期刊的少数论文具有很高的敏感性。
英文摘要:
We study how a single paper affects the Impact Factor (IF) by analyzing data from 3,088,511 papers published in 11639 journals in the 2017 Journal Citation Reports of Clarivate Analytics. We find that IFs are highly volatile. For example, the top-cited paper of 381 journals caused their IF to increase by more than 0.5 points, while for 818 journals the relative increase exceeded 25%. And one in 10 journals had their IF boosted by more than 50% by their top three cited papers. Because the single-paper effect on the IF is inversely proportional to journal size, small journals are rewarded much more strongly than large journals for a highly-cited paper, while they are penalized more for a low-cited paper, especially if their IF is high. This skewed reward mechanism incentivizes high-IF journals to stay small, to remain competitive in rankings. We discuss the implications for breakthrough papers appearing in prestigious journals. We question the reliability of IF rankings given the high IF sensitivity to a few papers for thousands of journals.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。