arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 0709.4531astro-ph
收藏

关于到大麦云云最近距离测量的聚类问题

A Problem with the Clustering of Recent Measures of the Distance to the Large Magellanic Cloud

Bradley E. Schaefer

摘要:

到大麦云(LMC)的距离一直是距离阶梯和所有星系距离的关键重要性,因此许多团体提供了许多方法和校准每种方法的各种方法来测量其距离模量(μ)。在2001年之前,许多指标的范围很广(大约18.1 < μ< 18.8),引用的误差线远小于差幅,因此一致的结论是,许多指标的不确定性主要是未被认识到的系统性问题。2001年,哈勃空间望远镜距离尺度重点项目(HSTKP)对早期的结果进行了广泛的分析,采用了距离模数为18.50 ± 0.10等的合理结论,社会上也普遍接受了这一广泛推广的数值。2002年之后,31篇独立论文向LMC报告了新的距离测量,这些测量紧紧围绕μ=18.50 mag。其中68%的测量值在18.50 mag.A的0.5-sigma范围内。Kolmogorov-Smirnov检验证明,该浓度偏离了预期的高斯分布,a >3。sigma概率水平这种集中是一个令人担忧的问题的症状。考虑的解释包括论文之间的相关性,误差线的普遍高估,以及跟风效应。本说明旨在提醒该领域的工作人员,这是一个应该解决的严重问题。

英文摘要:

The distance to the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) has long been of key importance for the distance ladder and the distances to all galaxies, and as such many groups have provided measurements of its distance modulus (μ) with many methods and various means of calibrating each method. Before the year 2001, the many measures spanned a wide range (roughly 18.1 < μ< 18.8) with the quoted error bars being substantially smaller than the spread, and hence the consensus conclusion being that many of the measures had their uncertainties being dominated by unrecognized systematic problems. In 2001, the Hubble Space Telescope Key Project (HSTKP) on the distance scale made an extensive analysis of earlier results and adopted the reasonable conclusion that the distance modulus is 18.50+-0.10 mag, and the community has generally accepted this widely popularized value. After 2002, 31 independent papers have reported new distance measures to the LMC, and these cluster tightly around μ=18.50 mag. Indeed, these measures cluster too tightly around the HSTKP value, with 68% of the measures being within 0.5-sigma of 18.50 mag. A Kolmogorov-Smirnov test proves that this concentration deviates from the expected Gaussian distribution at a >3-sigma probability level. This concentration is a symptom of a worrisome problem. Interpretations considered include correlations between papers, widespread over-estimation of error bars, and band-wagon effects. This note is to alert workers in the field that this is a serious problem that should be addressed.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑