In this note we give an example of a set $\W\subset \R^4$ such that $L^2(\W)$ admits an orthonormal basis of exponentials $\{\frac{1}{|\W |^{1/2}}e^{2πi x, ξ}\}_{ξ\inŁ}$ for some set $Ł\subset\R^4$, but which does not tile $\R^4$ by translations. This improves Tao's recent 5-dimensional example, and shows that one direction of Fuglede's conjecture fails already in dimension 4. Some common properties of translational tiles and spectral sets are also proved.
Fuglede's conjecture states that a subset $Ω\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{n}$ of positive and finite Lebesgue measure is a spectral set if and only if it tiles $\mathbb{R}^{n}$ by translation. The conjecture does not hold in both directions for $\mathbb{R}^n$, $n\ge3$. However, this conjecture remains open in $\mathbb{R}$ and $\mathbb{R}^2$. Cyclic groups play important roles in the study of Fuglede's conjecture in $\mathbb{R}$. In this paper, we introduce a new tool to study the spectral sets in cyclic groups. In particular, we prove that Fuglede's conjecture holds in $\mathbb{Z}_{p^{n}qr}$.
Fuglede's conjecture states that for a subset $Ω$ of a locally compact abelian group $G$ with positive and finite Haar measure, there exists a subset of the dual group of $G$ which is an orthogonal basis of $L^{2}(Ω)$ if and only if it tiles the group by translation. In this paper, we prove a divisibility property for a set in $\mathbb{Z}_{p}\times\mathbb{Z}_{p^{n}}$. Then using the divisibility property and equi-distributed property, we prove that Fuglede's conjecture holds in the group $\mathbb{Z}_{p}\times\mathbb{Z}_{p^{n}}$.
For p=5,7, we show that a subset \(E \subset \F_p^3\) is spectral if and only if E tiles \(\F_p^3\) by translation. Additionally, we give an alternate proof that the conjecture holds for p=3.
We give an example of a set $Ω\subset \R^5$ which is a finite union of unit cubes, such that $L^2(Ω)$ admits an orthonormal basis of exponentials $\{\frac{1}{|Ω|^{1/2}} e^{2πi ξ_j \cdot x}: ξ_j \in Λ\}$ for some discrete set $Λ\subset \R^5$, but which does not tile $\R^5$ by translations. This answers a conjecture of Fuglede in the negative, at least in 5 and higher dimensions.
We describe computer programs accompanying our paper and show that running them suffices to verify Fuglede's conjecture in $\mathbb{Z}_2^5$ and $\mathbb{Z}_2^6$.
The Fuglede conjecture states that a set is spectral if and only if it tiles by translation. The conjecture was disproved by T. Tao for dimensions 5 and higher by giving a counterexample in $\mathbb{Z}_3^5$. We present a computer program that determines that the Fuglede conjecture holds in $\mathbb{Z}_5^3$ by exhausting the search space. A. Iosevich, A. Mayeli and J. Pakianathan showed that the Fuglede conjecture holds over prime fields when the dimension does not exceed 2. The question for dimension 3 was previously addressed by Aten et al. for $p=3$. In this paper we build upon the results o…
In this short note we construct a spectral, non-tiling set of size $2p$ in $(\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z})^4$, $p$ odd prime. This example complements a previous counterexample in [arXiv:1509.01090], which existed only for $p \equiv 3 \pmod{4}$. On the contrary we show that the conjecture does hold in $(\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z})^4$.
We present an approach to Fuglede's conjecture in $\mathbb{Z}_p^3$ using linear programming bounds, obtaining the following partial result: if $A\subseteq\mathbb{Z}_p^3$ with $p^2-p\sqrt{p}+\sqrt{p}<|A|<p^2$, then $A$ is not spectral.
Let $Ω$ be a compact convex domain in the plane. We prove that $L^2(Ω)$ has an orthogonal basis of exponentials if and only if $Ω$ tiles the plane by translation.
Fuglede's spectral set conjecture states that a subset $Ω$ of a locally compact abelian group $G$ tiles the group by translation if and only if there exists a subset of continuous group characters which is an orthogonal basis of $L^2(Ω)$. We prove that Fuglede's conjecture holds on cyclic groups $\mathbb{Z}_{pqr}$ with $p,q,r$ distinct primes.
The study of Fuglede's conjecture on the direct product of elementary abelian groups was initiated by Iosevich et al. For the product of two elementary abelian groups the conjecture holds. For $\mathbb{Z}_p^3$ the problem is still open if $p\ge 11$. In connection we prove that Fuglede's conjecture holds on $\mathbb{Z}_{p}^2\times \mathbb{Z}_q$ by developing a method based on ideas from discrete geometry.
In this paper we study subsets $E$ of ${\Bbb Z}_p^d$ such that any function $f: E \to {\Bbb C}$ can be written as a linear combination of characters orthogonal with respect to $E$. We shall refer to such sets as spectral. In this context, we prove the Fuglede Conjecture in ${\Bbb Z}_p^2$ which says that $E \subset {\Bbb Z}_p^2$ is spectral if and only if $E$ tiles ${\Bbb Z}_p^2$ by translation. Arithmetic properties of the finite field Fourier transform, elementary Galois theory and combinatorial geometric properties of direction sets play the key role in the proof.
In this paper we prove the "Tiling implies Spectral" part of Fuglede's paper for the case of three intervals. Then we prove the "Spectral implies Tiling" part of the conjecture for the case of three equal intervals as also when the intervals have lengths 1/2, 1/4, 1/4. For the general case we change our approach to get information on the structure of the spectrum for the n-interval case. Finally, we use symbolic computations on Mathematica, and prove this part of the conjecture with an additional assumption on the spectrum.
Fuglede's conjecture in $\mathbb{Q}_p$ is proved. That is to say, a Borel set of positive and finite Haar measure in $\mathbb{Q}_p$ is a spectral set if and only if it tiles $\mathbb{Q}_p$ by translation.
The tile-spectral direction of the discrete Fuglede-conjecture is well-known for cyclic groups of square-free order, initiated by Laba and Meyerowitz, but the spectral-tile direction is far from being well-understood. The product of at most three primes as the order of the cyclic group was studied intensely in the last couple of years. In this paper we study the case when the order of the cyclic group is the product of four different primes and prove that Fuglede's conjecture holds in this case.
We investigate the discrete Fuglede's conjecture and Pompeiu problem on finite abelian groups and develop a strong connection between the two problems. We give a geometric condition under which a multiset of a finite abelian group has the discrete Pompeiu property. Using this description and the revealed connection we prove that Fuglede's conjecture holds for $\mathbb{Z}_{p^n q^2}$, where $p$ and $q$ are different primes. In particular, we show that every spectral subset of $\mathbb{Z}_{p^n q^2}$ tiles the group. Further, using our combinatorial methods we give a simple proof for the statement…
Recent methods developed by Tao \cite{tao}, Kolountzakis and Matolcsi \cite{nspec} have led to counterexamples to Fugelde's Spectral Set Conjecture in both directions. Namely, in $\RR^5$ Tao produced a spectral set which is not a tile, while Kolountzakis and Matolcsi showed an example of a non-spectral tile. In search of lower dimensional non-spectral tiles we were led to investigate the Universal Spectrum Conjecture (USC) of Lagarias and Wang \cite{lagwang}. In particular, we prove here that the USC and the ``tile $\to$ spectral'' direction of Fuglede's conjecture are equivalent in any dimens…
We show that the spectral set conjecture by Fuglede holds in the setting of cyclic groups of order $p^n q$, where $p$, $q$ are distinct primes and $n\geq1$. This means that a subset $E$ of such a group $G$ tiles the group by translation ($G$ can be partitioned into translates of $E$) if and only if there exists an orthogonal basis of $L^2(E)$ consisting of group characters. The main ingredient of the present proof is the structure of vanishing sums of roots of unity of order $N$, where $N$ has at most two prime divisors; the extension of this proof to the case of cyclic groups of order $p^n q^…
Fuglede's conjecture in $\mathbb{Z}_{p}^{d}$, $p$ a prime, says that a subset $E$ tiles $\mathbb{Z}_{p}^{d}$ by translation if and only if $E$ is spectral, meaning any complex-valued function $f$ on $E$ can be written as a linear combination of characters orthogonal with respect to $E$. We disprove Fuglede's conjecture in $\mathbb{Z}_{p}^{4}$ for all odd primes $p$, by using log-Hadamard matrices to exhibit spectral sets of size $2p$ which do not tile, extending the result of Aten et al. that the conjecture fails in $\mathbb{Z}_{p}^{4}$ for primes $p \equiv 3 \pmod 4$ and in $\mathbb{Z}_{p}^{5…
Let $Ω$ be a convex polytope in $\mathbb{R}^d$. We say that $Ω$ is spectral if the space $L^2(Ω)$ admits an orthogonal basis consisting of exponential functions. There is a conjecture, which goes back to Fuglede (1974), that $Ω$ is spectral if and only if it can tile the space by translations. It is known that if $Ω$ tiles then it is spectral, but the converse was proved only in dimension $d=2$, by Iosevich, Katz and Tao. By a result due to Kolountzakis, if a convex polytope $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^d$ is spectral, then it must be centrally symmetric. We prove that also all the facets of $Ω$ are c…
A set $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^d$ is said to be spectral if the space $L^2(Ω)$ has an orthogonal basis of exponential functions. It is well-known that in many respects, spectral sets "behave like" sets which can tile the space by translations. This suggests a conjecture that a product set $Ω= A \times B$ is spectral if and only if the factors $A$ and $B$ are both spectral sets. We recently proved this in the case when $A$ is an interval in dimension one. The main result of the present paper is that the conjecture is true also when $A$ is a convex polygon in two dimensions. We discuss this result i…
A set $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^d$ is said to be spectral if the space $L^2(Ω)$ has an orthogonal basis of exponential functions. A conjecture due to Fuglede (1974) stated that $Ω$ is a spectral set if and only if it can tile the space by translations. While this conjecture was disproved for general sets, it has long been known that for a convex body $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^d$ the "tiling implies spectral" part of the conjecture is in fact true. To the contrary, the "spectral implies tiling" direction of the conjecture for convex bodies was proved only in $\mathbb{R}^2$, and also in $\mathbb{R}^3$ und…
In this paper we study Fuglede's conjecture on the direct product of two cyclic groups. After collecting the known results we prove that Fuglede's conjecture holds on $\mathbb{Z}_{pq} \times \mathbb{Z}_{pq} \cong \mathbb{Z}_p^2 \times \mathbb{Z}_q^2$.
A conjecture of Fuglede states that a bounded measurable set $Ω$ in space, of measure 1, can tile space by translations if and only if the Hilbert space $L^2(Ω)$ has an orthonormal basis consisting of exponentials. If $Ω$ has the latter property it is called spectral. We generalize a result of Fuglede, that a triangle in the plane is not spectral, proving that every non-symmetric convex domain is not spectral.
We exhibit a subset of a finite Abelian group, which tiles the group by translation, and such that its tiling complements do not have a common spectrum (orthogonal basis for their $L^2$ space consisting of group characters). This disproves the Universal Spectrum Conjecture of Lagarias and Wang. Further, we construct a set in some finite Abelian group, which tiles the group but has no spectrum. We extend this last example to the groups $\ZZ^d$ and $\RR^d$ (for $d \ge 5$) thus disproving one direction of the Spectral Set Conjecture of Fuglede. The other direction was recently disproved by Tao.
In this paper, we show an equi-disctributed property in $2$-dimensional finite abelian groups $\mathbb{Z}_{p^2}\times \mathbb{Z}_{p}$ where $p$ is a prime number. By using this equi-disctributed property, we prove that Fuglede's spectral set conjecture holds on groups $\mathbb{Z}_{p^2}\times \mathbb{Z}_{p}$, namely, a set in $\mathbb{Z}_{p^2}\times \mathbb{Z}_{p}$ is a spectral set if and only if it is a tile.
A conjecture of Fuglede states that a bounded measurable set D, of measure 1, can tile space by translations if and only if the Hilbert space L^2(D) has an orthonormal basis consisting of exponentials exp(i 2 pi lambda x). If D has the latter property it is called spectral. Let D be a polytope with the following property: there is a direction u such that, of all the polytope faces perpendicular to u, the total area of the faces pointing in the positive u direction is more than the total area of the faces pointing in the negative u direction. It is almost obvious that such a polytope D cannot t…
We study tiling and spectral sets in vector spaces over prime fields. The classical Fuglede conjecture in locally compact abelian groups says that a set is spectral if and only if it tiles by translation. This conjecture was disproved by T. Tao in Euclidean spaces of dimensions 5 and higher, using constructions over prime fields (in vector spaces over finite fields of prime order) and lifting them to the Euclidean setting. Over prime fields, when the dimension of the vector space is less than or equal to $2$ it has recently been proven that the Fuglede conjecture holds (see \cite{IMP15}). In t…
A bounded measurable set $Ω\subset{\mathbb R}^d$ is called a spectral set if it admits some exponential orthonormal basis $\{e^{2πi \langleλ,x\rangle}: λ\inΛ\}$ for $L^2(Ω)$. In this paper, we show that in dimension one $d=1$, any spectrum $Λ$ with $0\inΛ$ of a spectral set $Ω$ with Lebesgue measure normalized to 1 must be rational. Combining previous results that spectrum must be periodic, the Fuglede's conjecture on ${\mathbb R}^1$ is now equivalent to the corresponding conjecture on all cyclic groups ${\mathbb Z}_{n}.$
Let $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}$ be a compact set with measure $1$. If there exists a subset $Λ\subset \mathbb{R}$ such that the set of exponential functions $E_Λ:=\{e_λ(x) = e^{2πi λx}|_Ω:λ\in Λ\}$ is an orthonormal basis for $L^2(Ω)$, then $Λ$ is called a spectrum for the set $Ω$. A set $Ω$ is said to tile $\mathbb{R}$ if there exists a set $\mathcal T$ such that $Ω+ \mathcal T = \mathbb{R}$. A conjecture of Fuglede suggests that Spectra and Tiling sets are related. Lagarias and Wang \cite {LW1} proved that Tiling sets are always periodic and are rational. That any spectrum is also a periodic set w…
By analyzing the connection between complex Hadamard matrices and spectral sets we prove the direction ``spectral -> tile'' of the Sectral Set Conjecture for all sets A of size at most 5 in any finite Abelian group. This result is then extended to the infinite grid $\Z^d$ for any dimension d, and finally to Euclidean space. It was pointed out recently by Tao that the corresponding statement fails for |A|=6 in the group $\Z_3^5$, and this observation quickly led to the failure of the Spectral Set Conjecture in $\R^5$ (Tao), and subsequently in $\R^4$ (Matolcsi). In the second part of this note …
