arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv cs/9903015cs.CYphysics.soc-ph
收藏

学术交流与电子出版的连续体

Scholarly Communication and the Continuum of Electronic Publishing

Rob Kling, Geoffrey McKim

摘要:

电子出版的机会,体现在今天的各种电子期刊和基于网络的纲要,已经抓住了许多学者的想象力。这些机会也动摇了一些领域关于合法学术出版性质的规范。不幸的是,许多关于学术电子出版的文献都将出版的特征同质化了。本文提供了一种分析方法,评估学科公约,并提出有关学术电子出版的政策。我们将学术出版的三个方面描述为一种交流实践--宣传、获取和可信度,并在这个框架内研究了几种形式的纸质和电子出版物。这一分析表明,电子出版"大大扩大了访问"的共同主张是如何过于简单化的。它还表明同行评审(无论是纸质还是电子)如何为学术交流提供了宝贵的功能,而这些功能并没有被电子媒体上的自贴文章所有效取代。

英文摘要:

Electronic publishing opportunities, manifested today in a variety of electronic journals and Web-based compendia, have captured the imagination of many scholars. These opportunities have also destabilized norms about the character of legitimate scholarly publishing in some fields. Unfortunately, much of the literature about scholarly e-publishing homogenizes the character of publishing. This article provides an analytical approach for evaluating disciplinary conventions and for proposing policies about scholarly e-publishing. We characterize three dimensions of scholarly publishing as a communicative practice -- publicity, access, and trustworthiness, and examine several forms of paper and electronic publications in this framework. This analysis shows how the common claim that e-publishing "substantially expands access" is over-simplified. It also indicates how peer-reviewing (whether in paper or electronically) provides valuable functions for scholarly communication that are not effectively replaced by self-posting articles in electronic media.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑