美国与欧洲无线标准制定的比较
Comparison of Wireless Standards-Setting --United States Versus Europe
摘要:
如果把制定标准的决定留给各个公司,有许多好处,包括对市场演变作出灵活反应,适应迅速的技术变化,避免代价高昂的协调。然而,市场进程并不一定导致兼容的标准,特别是在没有明确的市场支配者的情况下。标准机构通常促进市场参与者之间更好的沟通,这可能会阻止市场上出现早期和/或原始的不兼容标准。然而,机构标准制定方面的支出可能导致收益递减,甚至适得其反,因为机构标准通常需要更长的时间来制定,而且对技术发展的反应较慢。政府机构可以规定强制性标准,以避免不兼容。此外,政府可以将其标准化政策与其工业、贸易和/或监管政策紧密结合起来。然而,许多外部因素阻碍了政府的有效参与。政府往往未能对技术发展和消费者需求的动态作出反应,也未能选择“正确的技术”。本研究首先讨论了为什么两个地区出现了两种不同的模式。然后,它考察了两个模型的结果和影响,包括对国内服务部署,全球贸易竞争,技术创新和跨国公司的战略的影响。我们的目标是进行两个对比模型之间的实证比较。
英文摘要:
When decisions about developing standards are left to individual firms, there are many advantages including a flexible response to market evolution, accommodation to rapid technology change, and avoidance of costly coordination. However, the market process does not necessarily lead to compatible standards, especially when there is no clear market dominator. Standards Institutions generally facilitate better communication among market participants, which may discourage early and/or primitive incompatible standards to emerge in the market. However, expenditures on institutional standards-setting can lead to diminishing returns, or even be counter-productive because institutional standards usually take longer to produce and are slower to respond to technology development. Government agencies can specify compulsory standards to avoid incompatibility. In addition, governments can tie their policy on standardization closely with their industrial, trade, and/or regulatory policies. However, many exogenous factors handicap a government's effective involvement. Government often fails to respond to the dynamics of technology development and consumer demand, and to pick up the "right technology". This study first discusses why two different models have emerged in the two regions. It then examines outcomes and implications of the two models, including impacts on domestic service deployment, global trade competition, technology innovations, and strategies of multinational corporations. The goal is to conduct an empirical comparison between the two contrasting models.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。