arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2610.34933cs.SEcs.HC
收藏

什么将取代拉取请求?为智能体重新思考软件协作

What Will Replace Pull Requests? Rethinking Software Collaboration for AI Agents

Singapore Management University(新加坡管理大学);Heidelberg University(海德堡大学)

Christoph Treude, Sebastian Baltes

AI总结:

该研究针对AI编码智能体带来的拉取请求压力,审查50份灰色文献,分析从业者提出/采用的替代方案,指出仅Zed实际使用替代方案,最后提出相关研究议程。

摘要:

人工智能(AI)编码智能体的出现使拉取请求(pull requests)面临压力:智能体每月会发起数百万个拉取请求,而一些开源项目已开始限制或禁用外部贡献。我们研究从业者正在提出或采用的拉取请求替代方案,以及这些变化对实证软件工程研究的意义。我们审查了2025年10月至2026年10月期间31个组织或个人发布的50份灰色文献,对每份文献中指出的问题、提出或采用的机制、该机制承担的拉取请求的五个角色(集成、审查、依据、问责制、外部贡献)中的哪一个,以及提供的证据进行编码。大多数回应以某种形式保留了拉取请求,无论是添加工具、附加新工件还是限制访问,且限制是最常被报告采用的回应。一些提出的替代方案将审查和依据转移到智能体对话和会话记录中,但只有Zed报告实际使用了替代方案。仅有两份文献概述了外部贡献的替代方案,且均未报告被采用。拉取请求正在发生变化,而拉取请求数据集无法捕捉这些变化:在智能体对话中进行的审查不会留下拉取请求评论,禁用拉取请求的项目会从新发起的样本中消失。我们概述了关于新兴替代方案的有效性、它们对开源参与的影响以及实证方法调整的研究议程。

英文摘要:

The emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) coding agents has put pull requests under pressure: agents open millions of pull requests per month, while some open-source projects have begun to restrict or disable external contributions. We investigate which alternatives to pull requests practitioners are proposing or adopting and what these changes mean for empirical software engineering research. We reviewed 50 gray-literature documents from 31 organizations or individuals published between October 2025 and October 2026, coding the problems each named, the mechanisms it proposed or adopted, which of five roles of pull requests (integration, review, rationale, accountability, and external contribution) each mechanism takes over, and the evidence offered. Most responses retained pull requests in some form, whether by adding tooling, attaching a new artifact, or restricting access, and restriction was the response most often reported as adopted. Several proposed alternatives moved review and rationale into agent conversations and session records, but only Zed reported using a replacement in practice. Only two documents outlined a replacement for external contribution, and neither reported adoption. Pull requests are changing in ways that pull-request datasets will not capture: reviews conducted in agent conversations leave no pull-request comments, and projects that disable pull requests disappear from samples of newly opened ones. We outline a research agenda on the effectiveness of the emerging alternatives, their consequences for open-source participation, and the adaptation of empirical methods.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑