创建可持续和包容性福祉综合指数方法的比较综述
A Comparative Review of Methods to Create a Composite Index for Sustainable and Inclusive Wellbeing
AI总结:
研究旨在为可持续和包容性福祉创建综合指数,通过对比13种方法,依据九个条件评估,发现汇总选择影响排名且无单方法满足所有条件,提出未来综合指标需跨层次组合非线性归一化、非补偿性汇总等方法。
摘要:
社会目标需从过度依赖国内生产总值(GDP)转向更广泛的可持续和包容性福祉(SIW)。然而,定义和用单一数字衡量SIW存在问题,因其涉及众多以复杂非线性方式组合的主客观因素。传统方法要么采用线性加权平均,要么仅将SIW简化为主观福祉,均不充分。本文根据需求理论和强可持续性得出的九个条件,对SIW的汇总方法进行综述。比较了13种方法,从简单算术平均值到基于惩罚的指数等。示例表明汇总选择会显著改变国家排名,没有单一方法能满足所有九个条件。结论是未来的SIW综合指标需要跨层次组合方法。
英文摘要:
Societal goals need to shift from over-reliance on gross domestic product (GDP) to broader aspects of sustainable and inclusive wellbeing (SIW). However, defining SIW and eventually measuring it with a single number is problematic because it involves many subjective and objective contributors that combine in complex, non-linear ways. Conventional approaches either use linear weighted averages or reduce SIW to subjective wellbeing alone. Neither is sufficient. This paper reviews aggregation methods for SIW against nine conditions derived from needs theory and strong sustainability: limited substitutability, penalisation of imbalances, non-linear transformations, respect for environmental ceilings, respect for lower limits, a formative measurement model, no correlation requirement, distributional sensitivity, cross-border spillovers, and intertemporal aggregation. We compare 13 methods, from simple arithmetic means to penalty-based indices, outranking multicriteria, data envelopment analysis, and insights from ecology, neuroscience, and machine learning. Our illustrative example shows that aggregation choices change significantly country rankings. Compensatory methods create similar rankings. No single method satisfies all nine conditions. We conclude that a future SIW composite indicator will require combining methods across levels: non-linear normalisation, non-compensatory aggregation, and measurement-level choices for inclusiveness and spillovers. This paper provides a step towards the headline aggregated indicator advocated by the UN High-Level Expert Group on Beyond GDP.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。