LLM人格何时支持可视化设计?跨模型研究颜色分配与图表选择
When Do LLM Personas Support Visualization Design? A Cross-Model Study of Color Assignment and Chart Choice
AI总结:
本研究通过跨模型实验(GPT-4o-mini、GPT-4.1-mini、GPT-5-mini)和43个大五人格剖面,发现LLM人格在颜色分配任务中表现不稳定,而在图表选择任务中任务上下文比人格影响更大,表明LLM人格仅适合作为探索性工具而非人类替代。
摘要:
大型语言模型人格越来越多地被用于在早期可视化设计阶段近似不同用户,但尚不清楚人格条件化的输出是否反映稳定的人格效应,还是模型选择和任务框架的产物。我们通过两个可视化相关任务来检验这一问题:抽象和具体概念的颜色分配,以及跨任务上下文的图表惯用偏好评级。使用GPT-4o-mini、GPT-4.1-mini和GPT-5-mini上的43个大五人格剖面,我们发现人格-颜色耦合高度依赖于模型配置:在GPT-4o-mini中所有六个概念均不存在,在GPT-4.1-mini中所有六个概念一致存在,在GPT-5-mini中六个概念中的两个部分存在。概念类型进一步塑造了信号:对于抽象概念,人格比模型身份解释了更多的色调方差,而具体概念则显示出较小且可比较的影响。在图表选择中,特质对齐的聚类聚合在所有九个聚类-上下文组合中产生了稳定的顶级惯用排名,但在9个模型-上下文单元中的8个中,无人格基线恢复了相同的顶级选择,表明任务上下文比人格更能驱动排名第一的选择。这些发现将LLM人格定位为可视化设计的探索性探针,而非人类参与者的替代品,并激励未来研究中的多模型测试、概念类型分解和无人格基线。
英文摘要:
Large language model personas are increasingly used to approximate diverse users during early-stage visualization design, but it remains unclear whether persona-conditioned outputs reflect stable personality effects or artifacts of model choice and task framing. We examine this question across two visualization-relevant tasks: color assignment for abstract and concrete concepts, and chart-idiom preference ratings across task contexts. Using 43 Big Five profiles across GPT-4o-mini, GPT-4.1-mini, and GPT-5-mini, we find that personality-color coupling is highly model-configuration dependent: absent in GPT-4o-mini for all six concepts, consistent in GPT-4.1-mini across all six, and partial in GPT-5-mini for two of six. Concept type further shapes the signal: for abstract concepts, personality explains more hue variance than model identity, while concrete concepts show smaller and comparable effects. In chart choice, trait-aligned cluster aggregation produces stable top-idiom rankings across all nine cluster-context combinations, but a no-persona baseline recovers the same top choice in 8 of 9 model-context cells, indicating that task context drives rank-1 selection more than personality. These findings position LLM personas as exploratory probes for visualization design, not substitutes for human participants, and motivate multi-model testing, concept-type disaggregation, and no-persona baselines in future studies.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。