在工程教育中使用AI:基于明确目的的平衡行为
Using AI in engineering education: a balancing act, driven by clear purpose
AI总结:
基于对100名高等教育学生(主要来自工程领域)的问卷调查和文献综述,探讨学生如何使用和看待大语言模型(LLMs),并主张在工程教育中采用目的驱动、情境敏感的AI整合方法。
摘要:
基于对100名高等教育学生(主要来自工程相关领域)的问卷调查以及对近期文献的批判性回顾,本章考察了学生在工程教育中如何使用和看待大语言模型(LLMs)。学生主要看重LLMs在写作支持、概念澄清、编程辅助和头脑风暴方面的价值,同时表达了对不准确、偏见、过度依赖、学术诚信以及验证负担的担忧。通过分析两种主导隐喻,即LLMs作为“神谕”和“导师”,本章展示了这些系统如何培养出往往超出其实际能力的权威性、专业性和个性化学习的期望。本章进一步论证,学生对效率和个性化支持承诺的依恋反映了一种“残酷的乐观主义”,即LLMs的感知益处往往依赖于学生仍在发展的技能、警惕性和专业知识。总体而言,本章主张在工程教育中采用目的驱动和情境敏感的AI整合方法,强调批判性AI素养、反思性评估设计、教学谨慎性以及对更广泛的伦理和环境影响的考虑。
英文摘要:
Based on a questionnaire of 100 higher-education students, predominantly from engineering-related fields, and a critical review of recent literature, this chapter examines how students use and perceive Large Language Models (LLMs) in engineering education. Students primarily value LLMs for writing support, conceptual clarification, coding assistance, and brainstorming, while simultaneously expressing concerns about inaccuracies, bias, overreliance, academic integrity, and the burden of verification. Through an analysis of two dominant metaphors, namely LLMs as an "oracle" and as a "tutor," the chapter shows how these systems cultivate expectations of authority, expertise, and personalized learning that often exceed their actual capabilities. The chapter further argues that students' attachment to the promises of efficiency and personalized support reflects a form of "cruel optimism," where the perceived benefits of LLMs often depend on the very skills, vigilance, and expertise that students are still developing. Overall, the chapter argues for a purpose-driven and context-sensitive approach to AI integration in engineering education, emphasizing critical AI literacy, reflective assessment design, pedagogical caution, and consideration of broader ethical and environmental impacts.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。