与AI行动:基于交互的代理侵权责任框架
Acting with AI: An Interaction-Based Framework for Agentic Tort Liability
AI总结:
本文基于Bratman规划理论和普通法人类协同行动原则,提出一种交互分类框架(自主漂移、纯工具使用、协作规划)来分配AI代理系统的侵权责任,并引入“合理代理”标准。
摘要:
代理AI系统能够多步规划、使用工具并随时间执行任务。当此类系统造成损害时,侵权法难以分配责任,因为有害路径可能既非用户完全选择,也非开发者特别预见。本文借鉴Michael Bratman的规划理论和普通法对人类协同行动的处理,提出一个基于交互的代理侵权框架。我们区分三种交互类型:自主漂移、纯工具使用和协作规划。纯工具案例仍受普通产品缺陷和警告原则管辖;协作规划案例映射到独立承包商控制测试、专业过失和过失性虚假陈述;自主漂移则映射到雇主责任下的“擅自行动”和严格产品责任。该框架将有状态交互日志作为主要证据线索,使法院能够推断人-AI轨迹何时偏离授权行为以及责任应归于何处。我们解决了四个事件锚定案例,将该观点与严格责任和基于保险的提案并列,指出其与监管监督的关系,并提出了一个围绕约束验证、认知透明度、运行时基础和取证日志构建的“合理代理”标准。
英文摘要:
Agentic AI systems can plan over multiple steps, use tools, and execute tasks over time. When such systems cause harm, tort law struggles to allocate responsibility because the harmful path may be neither fully chosen by the user nor specifically foreseen by the developer. This paper proposes an interaction-based framework for agentic torts, drawing on Michael Bratman's planning theory and on the common law's treatment of human-human concerted action. We distinguish three interaction types: autonomous drift, pure tool use, and collaborative planning. Pure tool cases remain governed by ordinary product-defect and warning doctrines; collaborative planning cases map onto the independent contractor control test, professional malpractice, and negligent misrepresentation; autonomous drift maps onto frolic and detour under respondeat superior and strict product liability. The framework treats the stateful interaction log as the primary evidentiary trace, allowing courts to infer where the human-AI trajectory departed from the authorized undertaking and where liability should attach. We resolve four incident-anchored cases, situate the account alongside strict-liability and insurance-based proposals, note its relationship to regulatory oversight, and propose a ``Reasonable Agent'' standard built around constraint verification, epistemic transparency, runtime grounding, and forensic logging.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。