能力的幻觉:欧洲中学生自我感知的数字素养与人工智能准备度
The Illusion of Competence: Self-Perceived Digital Literacy and AI Readiness Among European Secondary Students
AI总结:
本研究通过调查243名欧洲中学生,发现自我感知的数字素养与实际技术准备度之间存在严重信心-能力鸿沟,表现为集体邓宁-克鲁格效应,并揭示了技术性别差距仅在技术导向课堂中显著,以及学生高估自身对深度伪造和算法偏见批判意识的“AI悖论”,最终提出需以主动技术创造取代被动理论教学。
摘要:
数字设备的无处不在巩固了“数字原生代”范式,假设当代青年天生具备技术熟练度。这项多中心研究($N=243$名欧洲中学生)通过调查自我感知的数字素养与实际技术准备度(包括人工智能交互)之间的差距,挑战了这一叙事。我们的发现揭示了一种严重的信心-能力鸿沟,其特征是集体邓宁-克鲁格效应:学生在被动数字消费方面报告接近最大的自我效能,但在评估主动技术创造和算法逻辑时表现出急剧下降。至关重要的是,路径内分析表明,技术性别差距并非普遍存在;相反,它仅在技术导向的课堂中显著出现($p = 0.046$),表明在正式STEM环境中“刻板印象威胁”持续存在。此外,该研究揭示了“AI悖论”,即学生显著高估了自己对深度伪造和算法偏见的批判意识,而低估了其操作AI技能,从而对现代错误信息产生虚假的安全感。最终,在压倒性的学生改革需求($76.5\%$)支持下,本研究得出结论:消除这种能力幻觉需要放弃被动的理论教学,转而采用动手的、主动的技术创造。
英文摘要:
The ubiquitous presence of digital devices has cemented the 'Digital Native' paradigm, assuming inherent technological proficiency among contemporary youth. This multicenter study ($N=243$ European secondary students) challenges this narrative by investigating the gap between self-perceived digital literacy and actual technical readiness, including Artificial Intelligence (AI) interaction. Our findings reveal a severe Confidence-Competence Divide characterized by a collective Dunning-Kruger effect: students report near-maximum self-efficacy in passive digital consumption but exhibit a sharp decline when evaluating active technological creation and algorithmic logic. Crucially, an intra-pathway analysis demonstrates that the technological gender gap is not universal; rather, it emerges significantly exclusively within Technology-oriented classrooms ($p = 0.046$), indicating the persistence of 'stereotype threat' in formal STEM environments. Additionally, the study uncovers an 'AI Paradox' wherein students significantly overestimate their critical awareness of deepfakes and algorithmic biases compared to their operational AI skills, fostering a false sense of invulnerability against modern misinformation. Ultimately, supported by an overwhelming student demand ($76.5\%$) for pedagogical reform, this research concludes that dismantling this illusion of competence requires abandoning passive theoretical instruction in favor of hands-on, active technological creation.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。