arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2605.07993cs.LGstat.ME
收藏

基于证据先验的因果推断估计的贝叶斯敏感性

Bayesian Sensitivity of Causal Inference Estimators under Evidence-Based Priors

University of Toronto(多伦多大学);Vector Institute(向量研究所);University of Waterloo(滑铁卢大学)

Nikita Dhawan, Daniel Shen, Leonardo Cotta, Chris J. Maddison

AI总结:

本文提出贝叶斯敏感性值(BSV)框架,用于评估因果推断估计在假设违反下的稳健性,通过实证研究展示其在糖尿病治疗与体重损失关系中的应用。

摘要:

因果推断,尤其是在观察性研究中,依赖于关于真实数据生成过程的不可检验假设。敏感性分析帮助我们确定在改变这些底层假设时结论的稳健性。现有敏感性分析框架关注最坏情况下的假设变化。本文认为使用这种悲观标准有时会导致无信息或得出与现实世界知识矛盾的结论。为此,我们扩展了最近的s值框架(Gupta & Rothenhäusler, 2023),以估计因果推断中三种常见假设的敏感性。实证研究表明,最坏情况下的敏感性结论可能依赖于不现实的数据生成过程变化。为解决此问题,我们扩展s值框架,引入新的敏感性分析标准:贝叶斯敏感性值(BSV),该方法在基于现实世界证据构建的先验下计算估计对假设违反的期望敏感性。我们使用蒙特卡洛近似法估计此量,并在糖尿病治疗与体重损失的观察性研究中展示其应用。

英文摘要:

Causal inference, especially in observational studies, relies on untestable assumptions about the true data-generating process. Sensitivity analysis helps us determine how robust our conclusions are when we alter these underlying assumptions. Existing frameworks for sensitivity analysis are concerned with worst-case changes in assumptions. In this work, we argue that using such pessimistic criteria can often become uninformative or lead to conclusions contradicting our prior knowledge about the world. To demonstrate this claim, we generalize the recent s-value framework (Gupta & Rothenhäusler, 2023) to estimate the sensitivity of three different common assumptions in causal inference. Empirically, we find that, indeed, worst-case conclusions about sensitivity can rely on unrealistic changes in the data-generating process. To overcome this, we extend the s-value framework with a new sensitivity analysis criterion: Bayesian Sensitivity Value (BSV), which computes the expected sensitivity of an estimate to assumption violations under priors constructed from real-world evidence. We use Monte Carlo approximations to estimate this quantity and illustrate its applicability in an observational study on the effect of diabetes treatments on weight loss.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑