构建还是不构建?导致AI系统不发展或放弃的因素
To Build or Not to Build? Factors that Lead to Non-Development or Abandonment of AI Systems
AI总结:
本文探讨了影响AI系统不发展或放弃的关键因素,通过文献综述和案例研究,识别了伦理、反馈、生命周期挑战等六类因素,并指出现有研究需更全面地考虑非伦理相关因素。
摘要:
负责任的AI研究通常关注已部署系统的使用和影响,但对部署前的决策缺乏可见性。本文通过文献综述和案例研究,提出了六个导致AI系统放弃的因素分类:伦理问题、利益相关者反馈、开发生命周期挑战、组织动态、资源限制和法律监管问题。通过实证分析,本文揭示了组织放弃AI开发的多样化原因,而非仅限于伦理风险,并指出当前研究需更全面地考虑这些因素。
英文摘要:
Responsible AI research typically focuses on examining the use and impacts of deployed AI systems. Yet, there is currently limited visibility into the pre-deployment decisions to pursue building such systems in the first place. Decisions taken in the earlier stages of development shape which systems are ultimately released, and therefore represent potential, but underexplored, points for intervention. As such, this paper investigates factors influencing AI non-development and abandonment throughout the development lifecycle. Specifically, we first perform a scoping review of academic literature, civil society resources, and grey literature including journalism and industry reports. Through thematic analysis of these sources, we develop a taxonomy of six categories of factors contributing to AI abandonment: ethical concerns, stakeholder feedback, development lifecycle challenges, organizational dynamics, resource constraints, and legal/regulatory concerns. Then, we collect data on real-world case of AI system abandonment via an AI incident database and a practitioner survey to evidence and compare factors that drive abandonment both prior to and following system deployment. While academic responsible AI communities often emphasize ethical risks as reasons to not develop AI, our empirical analysis of these cases demonstrates the diverse, and often non-ethics-related, levers that motivate organizations to abandon AI development. Synthesizing evidence from our taxonomy and related case study analyses, we identify gaps and opportunities in current responsible AI research to (1) engage with the diverse range of levers that influence organizations to abandon AI development, and (2) better support appropriate (dis)engagement with AI system development.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。