排序选择联合实验
Ranked-choice conjoint experiments
AI总结:
本文探讨了如何将排序结果整合到联合分析框架中,发现排序选择联合实验能更精确地估计AMCE,推荐K=4个profile用于大多数应用。
摘要:
强制选择联合设计已成为实验工具箱中的标准方法。然而,强制选择结果并不总是符合个体在真实政治环境中的选择类型,也不具有统计效率。本文正式阐述了如何将排序结果整合到联合框架中。我们证明了排名扩展估计器等同于传统AMCE,提供了额外配置如何提高联合设计效率的理论解释,并设计了用于检验扩展基础的transitivity和independence of irrelevant alternatives假设的基于设计的检验。在两个预注册调查实验中,我们发现排序选择联合实验在实质上相似但更精确的AMCE估计,使用一个额外配置可将标准误差缩小12-13%,使用六个配置则可缩小达55%。基于效率-有效性权衡,我们推荐K=4个profile用于大多数应用。我们提供了一个配套的开源R包cjrank,实现了排名扩展、AMCE估计、效率诊断和本文描述的假设检验。
英文摘要:
Forced-choice conjoint designs have become a staple method in the experimentalist's toolkit. However, the forced-choice outcome is neither always consistent with the types of choices individuals make in real political contexts, nor is it statistically efficient. In this paper, we formalize how ranked outcomes can be integrated into the conjoint framework. We provide a proof that rank-expanded estimators are equivalent to conventional AMCE, a theoretical account of how additional profiles increase the efficiency of conjoint designs, and design-based tests for the transitivity and independence of irrelevant alternatives assumptions that underpin the expansion. Across two pre-registered survey experiments--the first comparing forced-choice and ranked-choice designs across candidate and policy domains, and the second varying the number of ranked profiles--we find that ranked-choice conjoints yield substantively similar but more precise AMCE estimates, shrinking standard errors by 12-13% with one additional profile and up to 55% with six profiles per vignette. Based on efficiency--validity trade-offs, we recommend K = 4 profiles for most applications. We provide an accompanying open-source R package, cjrank, that implements rank expansion, AMCE estimation, efficiency diagnostics, and the assumption tests described in this paper.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。